February 2019
Hi,
I’m thinking of changing my car, the Mazda 3 skyactiv 2.2 Diesel look good, and the specs sound good, but what are they like ? any like engine problems? Read more
Hi All,
We looked at a 67 plate seat Leon today. Got the car transferred over from Norwich as it was the right spec, colour, price.However upon giving it a test drive the EPC and engine warning lights were on. Petrol 1.4 engine.
The garage are going to look at it in the workshop on Monday and let us know what’s wrong etc and get it fixed. We will then have a three month warranty with the garage. Carshop in Northampton.
Just wondering what the general consensus is whether you would buy a 67 plate car that had these lights on or look for another one?
Cheers. Read more
“All cars had highly inflated prices but buyers got £1000 minimum for their old car.”
Mob I used to work for occasionally tried the £1,000 minimum trade-in ploy. I was sent out to add between £500-£1,000 to the sticker prices of a list of old stock no one wanted.
No free lunches in this game I’m aftaid. There’s no way a dealer can give £1,000 for a £200 nail and still make a decent profit on a used car unless it’s overpriced to start with.
Is there any evidence for or against long life service intervals ie 20,000 miles for a modern petrol engine such as the one in my Polo?
My understanding is they were created to satisfy fleet owners, many of which flog cars when two years old, and others have high annual mileage. These people probably don’t keep a car beyond 100,000 miles or six years, possibly less. Car manufacturers probably do not care once the car is six years old, their legal obligations are by then discharged. Read more
<< When we bought the Superb the 2 year fixed plan cost me £272 (which was included in the 0% finance deal I got). It was serviced approx 4 weeks ago and if it had been on variable servicing the £369 would have applied. By using fixed servicing I have saved £97. >>
So I would only ask - what's in it for the VAG dealers?...
Hi I have a Peugeot 3008 2011 1.6 HDI SPORT I have had a problem with the air bag light coming on and off sometimes could drive for 30 minutes and it comes on or it could be when the heaters are on full. I have changed my car battery has the old one was very low on voltage and thought this was the problem I have had the error read and it comes up with Level 1 driver airbag fault high stop distance ? can anyone please tell me what this is and also has I have put a new car battery on does the error just need removing now or could it be something eles I also have a 5 week old grandson in the car Read more
I know a couple of comms repairers and although none of them will do repairs on anything after a COMM2000 unit, they do sell refurbished ones with guarantees.
Both advertise online and on Ebay, one is in Wigan, the other Bradford.
I'm in the market for a used car with about £4,500 to spend. For me it's a toss up between a Honda Jazz or Skoda Fabia. I like the extra room of the Jazz, I very slightly prefer the way the Fabias drive. I will get a newer/lower mileage Fabia for the same money.
As a very approximate perceived average of what's out there, it seems that £4,500 will buy me a 13 plate Fabia that's done 50k, or a 60 plate Jazz that's done 60k
Any thoughts/preferences? Read more
Bloke I know has a 1.2 Fabia with well over 300k on the clock so they seem like a good longterm bet.
Well if you believe our resident ex motor trader SLO, this could well be the exception. According to him, they are not that reliable.
Hi all, I would be very grateful for any advice here.
I am not a mechanic at all, just a bit of a DIYer, but I definitely wouldn't try and repair anything as advanced as a cambelt. But I'm not completely clueless as to how it works.
Sorry for how long this post is, I just wanted to give all the facts rather than half a story...
Last week my girlfriend's 2011 Peugeot 207 broke down whilst waiting at some traffic lights, I wasn't with her at the time.
A friendly mechanic in the car behind her helped her push the car out of the way and tried starting it a few times, saying he thinks the cambelt had gone.
The AA then eventually turned up and tried starting it a few times and said the same thing - cambelt gone. They towed the car back to her house.
The next day she had a family friend mechanic come out and try and start the car again, and again saying it SOUNDS like the cambelt has gone.
So 3 people so far have said it's the cambelt.
But none of the 3 actually took anything apart, they just listened.
I went round hers at the weekend with my tools and took the top plastic cambelt cover off to have a look as it was just 2 bolts, but the belt wasn't snapped and was still tight in place!
I got her to try starting the car whilst I watched the belt (enough people had already tried to start it themselves so we had nothing to lose), see video I recorded in the streamable link below (with sound), it basically looked like something was stuck and the belt rapidly moved back and forth. The video is here...
streamable.com/jr4bi
Some further checks I did...
- Oil level is ok.
- Coolant level slightly below minimum, and a bit of sludge in there (has always been very dirty in there and Google images show the same on other 207's), but has correct level of protection.
- Took engine cover off but didn't reveal anything as too much oil in there, but what I did see all looked ok.
Some further info about the engine...
- 1.4
- 8v
- Engine code: TU3A (KFV)
- 75k miles done.
Looking at AutoTrader the car could be sold for about £1500 if it was in working condition.
So we're in 3 minds about it...
- Do we pay (a lot) to have it repaired?
- Do we scrap it?
- Do we sell it privately as spares/repairs?
We just want closure before we make the decision really, the thought of scrapping it when it was a possible easy fix for a mechanic will forever haunt us lol.
I've created an imgur album of photos I have taken myself, and some from random Google searches, the album is here...
imgur.com/a/Al3NZ9V
Can anyone tell me the official name for the zip tie clips that I had to snip off the cable that was across the top of the cambelt cover? If we are going to keep the car I need to find 2 replacement clips.
Thank you for reading and any advice on what's possibly broken here is much appreciated.
Cheers! Read more
The video seems to show that the cambelt (a) looks in fair condition and (b) hardly moves the camshaft. Maybe the tensioner has failed? If the valves are OK (get a compression test) a new belt and tensioner kit might rescue the engine at reasonable cost. It takes an awful lot of missing teeth for a belt to slip on those big sprockets.
But only a few missing to slip on the little crank sprocket which has half the number of teeth of the big cam sprocket(s). Further to my last flippant post, this cambelt design is intrinsically poor, as instead of wrapping itself around as many teeth as possible on the little crank sprocket, it is diverted at an angle to drive the water pump, the bearing of which (and/or that of the tensioner pulley) I suspect has become stiff, causing the crank sprocket (not the cam, Big John) to tear off the few teeth it is in contact with at any one time....
I would love to hear from any owners of pre 2016 Audi’s with 3.0tdi engines who have experienced the same as this To whom it may Concern Tuesday, 05 February 2019 Audi A7 First Registered 30 June 2015 Current Mileage 23900 approx. On the 22nd January 2019 I presented the above vehicle to Huddersfield Audi for the second and final service under its initial service plan. I was advised that there was an emissions software upgrade available. I declined to have this applied to the vehicle at this time. Upon arriving to collect the vehicle. I was cautioned not to drive it further as a rattle had been “discovered” emanating from the rear off side of the engine. My service representative and the service manager together attempted to demonstrate this rattle to me but I was unable to hear it. However, this I was assured, was indicative of a serious defect of the timing chain tensioner. Failure of this part was liable to cause catastrophic engine failure and damage. The only recourse, I was informed, was to strip the engine down and replace camshafts and belt tensioners. The garage was familiar with this fault which they informed me they had come across before with the 3.0 V6 TDi engine. It had indeed been the subject of a Technical Service Bulletins from Audi, the manufacturers. I have an email from my service representative, containing the following text, "Following on from the conversation with Audi UK, as I mentioned to you on Tuesday as a centre we have experienced similar noises on the A7 3 Litre's previously. Along with & we this a modified Camshaft has in fact been released from Audi as opposed to the original camshaft fitted within the vehicle from factory have confirmed similar faults with our technical team in Milton Keynes." Given the serious nature of this defect, I felt compelled to leave the vehicle where it was whilst I explored the options available to me. It was initially suggested to me, that under the circumstance, given the age of the vehicle (just seven months out of warrantee) and its low recorded mileage, there was a good possibility that Audi UK would meet the full costs of the replacement of the faulty parts. They would replace them with the redesigned afore mentioned parts. From this, I assumed that this garage had knowledge of customers who had the same repair carried out free of charge. As this was a 35 hours service operation @ approximately £100 per hour plus parts and VAT the final cost was somewhere in the region of £5000 +. Unfortunately it transpired that Audi UK informed the garage that I was required to make a contribution of some £2100 towards the cost. When I asked why I had not received the same generosity as other clients, I was informed that these matters were dealt with on a “case by case basis”. I have asked what criteria are used in determining an individual case. I have yet to receive an answer to this enquiry. As my vehicle is just out of warrantee and with a very low mileage the only criteria for making this discriminatory decision can be my age. At sixty nine, and relatively close to finishing driving, my potential loyalty to the brand must be somewhat limited. I left the car with the garage on the understanding that no further work would be carried out until I had been given a chance to take the matter up with Audi UK. I exchanged e-mails and telephone conversations with a Mr Mohammed Nasar, apparently the senior decision maker at Audi UK. Despite the information supplied by my garage as to the common nature of this fault and a number of website references from Audi owners club and many other sites the addresses of which I have supplied as an attachment, Mr Nasar insisted that there were no other recorded instances of this problem. When informed that Huddersfield Audi had experience at least two others he actually said to me “There must be something peculiar about Huddersfield.” I pointed out that I had purchased this vehicle in Beckenham to no avail. I received an email from him stating that there was no further assistance forth coming from either Huddersfield Audi or Audi UK and that my case was being archived Under these circumstances I saw no other option than to agree to have this work carried out. I negotiated further with Huddersfield Audi and agreed to pay £1500 inclusive of VAT. I made it clear both verbally and in e-mails that I was agreeing to this arrangement under duress and that I intended to seek redress later. Initially by a submission to the motor ombudsman whilst simultaneously seeking the assistance of consumer protection lawyers. When I came to collect my vehicle I requested that the paperwork be marked “paid under protest” This request was refused. In anticipation of this I had prepared a document a copy of which can be supplied, which outlined the circumstances leading to the repair and asked for an acknowledgement of my “paid under protest” status. The service representative said he was unable to sign this document but he would refer it to his line manager. The service manager has refused to sign this document and confirmed his refusal in an e mail. A simple trawl of the internet turns up many references to timing chain tensioner faults with a number of different engines fitted to vehicles across the VW/Audi group. It would seem that VW have settled a class action claim in respect to this in the USA. I would contend that this is a safety issue. The catastrophic failure of an engine in moving traffic would surely create the potential for accidents. Under these circumstances a general recall of vehicles likely to be affected should have been made. Read more
You can extend the warranty on VAG cars to five years for a tiny fraction of the cost of the car.
Effectively the additional warranty is an optional extra. Many of these cars are sold to fleets who won't be keeping them for more than three years, so they don't take up the option.
Around 18 December 2018 I purchased my 530D from an independent dealership, it was 2015 model. I part exchanged a 2011 520D for this car.
Few days later I needed to check with BMW regarding software update, and I was informed that the car had a recall on EGR Cooling, and they booking me into come on the 17.th of January. I was told if they discovered an issue they would need to keep the car for 48 hours and I would get a hire car.... Read more
Surely you should be directing your anger towards BMW who failed to design a safe car in the first place and then has messed up rectifying the issue not the dealer who sold it, possibly in good faith?
I presume the loan car is "under warranty" in that if it goes wrong whilst you're using it, it will be repaired/replaced. ...
Hi,
Was just driving the all of a sudden 4 warning lights came on. The ABS one, the TC one, and the ESC warning light, as well as the light telling me the ESC was switched off!! I got home, left it... and when I went out for another drive all the lights had disappeared... a week later (and driving it most days), it's now reappeared.... Read more
The last one of these I looked at ,had an odd size tyre fitted.
I heard a recent tale of an Austin 7 that was leaning to one side. The obvious (springs) were checked but nothing found. Eventually it was measured side to side, the height of the front hubs were found to be 3/8" different, the rears less so. All the tyres were marked 4.00 x 8, but when compared side to side off the car there was an obvious disparity. Swapping the wheels from one side to the other improved it no end. It still leans, but it's an eighty year old car....
I am by my own admission a bit of a car cleaning freak, wash the car weekly come rain or shine, wax every fortnight, I've even recently discovered the delights of "wheel wax ", my question is what is the consensus on the use of tyre black?
Been reading recently that heavy use of it can lead to tyre damage....any thoughts chaps?... Read more
<< if you're not really careful, it could impede the traction of the tyres >>
I'm pretty sure that any on the tread surface would be scuffed off in a very short time. Puddles of diesel on the road must be more of a worry - to say nothing of rainwater.
No need for question marks: coming from Andy, it will be sound advice.
In his second para he sets out very clearly the risks of buying a used diesel car.