December 2005

irv

Incredibly gutted.

Last Wednesday, both myself and my girlfriend had the day off. We were on our way to York to buy a new shower as ours had packed in the day before. I work in York, and my usual work commute is 22 miles door to door. I drive there and back every day and have done so since I bought the car in August.

The road from where i live to York is the A19. It's mostly national speed limit with three villages along the way, two of them 30mph zones. The first village is known as "Death Hill" due to the number of accidents that have happened there over the years. It is a very steep hill and people used to drive too fast over it (some still do), it has recently been changed from a 40 to a 30.

Pleased to say I negotiated this fine. About 5 miles prioir to getting here though I came up to the back of a couple of cars. The one directly infront of me was a black coupe. It was either a Honda or a Hyundai, but I honestly wasn't close enough to distinguish the difference in the badges.

I'm a sensible driver; I'm 22, but I was hit by a car 10 years ago and my girlfriend's dad was killed by a drunk driver. I certainly appreciate road safety. As a result, I was about 4 car lengths behind the car infront of me doing about 45 after we'd gone through death hill. As my girlfriend always says, "only a fool breaks the two second rule".

After death hill its back to national speed limit and over a slight hill. As I have said, I was doing about 45 and keeping station with the car in front. We accelerated very slowly out of death hill but there's no where to safely over take and I wasn't in a rush so I just kept my distance. we went over the crest of the hill and down the other side, so i could only see the car infront of me and not the car infront of him (or her)... when the coupe infront of me suddenly swerved round the car infront of me, complete with screeching brakes and everything. I immediately slammed all on and also tried to move round but my car doesn't have ABS brakes, so you tend to brake in a straight line. I unfortunately skidded down the hill into the back of the car that was infront of the car infront of me. If you get my meaning.
(i'm not 100% convinced i did turn the wheel at all, looking at the angle it ended up in it looks more like my backend stepped out under the heavy brakiing down hill but i'm no expert)

It was a big enough impact and both myself and my girlfirend were understandably shocked. The car that was infront of me drove off, leaving just myself and the car I hit. A Mercedes.

The Merc had a broken bumper, I asked the woman if she was OK but she just wanted my details, which we exchanged and she drove off. I called the police but there weren't interested. My car was blocking the road!

I got a farmer to give me a tow into a layby on the other side of the road and a copper showed up, breathalised me, checked my insurance, etc. He never asked me what happened. (Needless to say, i passed the breathaliser).

My car wouldn't start and my girlfriend was pretty shook up so I arranged for a lift for her from a family member and then payed £55 to have my car towed back.

It wasn't until the weekend when i got around to looking and found where the fuel isolation switch was. The car runs fine, with no damage to the radiator or anything as the impact eneded up being on the passenger side. The crash damage is as follows: dented bumper, slightly buckled wings, one smashed headlight (passenger side) and the other headlight has a broke clip, damaged bumper and damaged front panel. More worryingly, part of the chassis arm is sticking through the bumper.

Now, I own a 1998 Honda Civic Illusion, 1.4litre engine. I'm no boy racer, I bought it because Honda have legendry reliability and because it was the only car I could afford at the time (£1400). The car its self is in insurance category 7 (!) so fully comp insurance was 5 pounds cheaper than the actual cost of the car(cheapest quote i could get). So, Third party fire & theft was half that much, so i plummed for that instead. My reasoning being, I planned to buy a better car in the new year and it didn't seem very smart to pay that much on what was in their eyes a cheap car.

Rather annoyingly, 2 weeks ago I got a stone chip kicked up at my windscreen which actually prodcued a 14 inch crack. No fully comp, so I paid £125 to have that replaced. Infact, just last week, I bougth a set of 4 brand new Continental tyres for it (glad I did, accident might have been much worse without the grip).

Because there's no independent witnesses, and because I have only third party cover, my insurance company don't care very much, likely due to the fact it does seem to them i just ran into the back of another car despite my explaining it to them the best i could.

It's extremely frustrating because I know it wasn't 100% my fault, i've yeat to hear a good explanation of why I came face to bumper with a near stationary vehicle and what happened to make it stop, why the car infront of me had to swerve (i can speculate he was too close but that doesn't really help me). In the back of my mind i also have a nagging question about why i wasn't able to stop before the impact, but the speed difference between the two cars was fairly large (before i slowed it down)

Because I don't have fully comp, I have to foot the bill unless the other pary accepts blame, which they won't. Fair enough. Except I had a quote from the garage that has serviced the car since it was first registered in 1998 (and kept it in very nice condition)... They tell me the chassis is twisted slightly due to the uneven impact and will need to be put on a jig to correct it. They estimate that to cost at least £100, plus about 8 hours labour. Then there's parts and spraying and fitting... he said he'd be surprised if it wasn't at least £2K.

That's obviousley more than the car is worth. Insultingly, he offered me £250 for it in scrap because it had new tyres (which cost me £190 last week!). he was very keen not to do any work at all.

I really don't know what to do. I live in a fairly rural area and I need my car to get to work in a reasonable amount of time. I've been taking a train and 2 busses which works out at about £12 per day at the moment and adds at least an hour to it if everythign is on time. I spent about £20/week in petrol before.

There's not many cheap cars for sale locally, but about 15 miles down the road there is a nice 2001 reg civic for £3k, insurance cat 4... even with the accident on record i can get fully comp for it for about half the cost of the vehicle, but what do i do about my existing car and insurance (and road tax?)

Any advice or suggestions at all from anyone would be appreciated. As I've said, the important thing is that nobody was hurt(i wasn't even sore but my girlfriend had a sore back for a few days) and I just want to get things sorted out as quickly as possibly.

obviousley a garage wouldn't have to pay for labour to fix the car and could replace the body work at cost, etc. With that in mind, do you think any garages would take the car in part exchange? It has a full service history, the rest of the car (including engine) are in excellent condition, its just too costly for me to fix because of the labour.

or is a second opinion warranted? Read more

Cardew

Similar Thread here:

forums.moneysavingexpert.com/showthread.html?t=126...4

Question Mk IV Golf
grahamwiz

help !! Does anyone know if you can adjust the timing on a Mk IV 1.4 golf. Recently had the timing cambelt changed, and the engine sort of chugs on tick over, returned it to the garage and they dont seem able to rectify.

Thanks -- Graham Read more

Xileno {P}

Sounds to me like a tooth is out.
Take it back and tell them to do it properly.

IrishFrank

I have a problem with my vectra TD.

From cold things are ok

Once up to temperature driving normally is fine.

If you have to stop for a light the engine light comes on and power is severly reduced.

This could be very interesting at a junction or roundabout.

The car is underpowered for maybe 15 20 seconds then seems to normalise.

If the car is left to cool down for a bit then the problem dissapears again until the temp comes up.

Gave the car a service recently this didn't help.

Any ideas?

Frank

Read more

IrishFrank

Thanks Bikemade

Just to be a nuissance is there any way to check this without a computer?

Check a voltage something like that?

bhoy wonder

Twice driving into work this week I have had to pull over to let Ambulances by myself. Only for the car several yards behind to pull out once that ambulance has past by and speed up to stop myself and several other drivers pulling back into the road. This morning when it happened it nearly caused a crash and the person in the car behind me was so infuriated that has car was rolling from side to side.

Is this a common experience that has happened to anyone else? Or has just been my luck that I have come across a couple of idiots on the road.
Read more

spikeyhead {p}

Whilst out walking a month ago I saw a friend and asked him where he was going carrying a suitcase. He reploed that he was taking his case to court.

I saw him again today, carrying a ladder as well as a suitcase. He was taking it to a higher court.

I'll get my coat.
--
I read often, only post occasionally

bikemade3

£18K buys a new Mondeo 3.0 V6 ST 220 i think that's a bargain but for the money is the new Vectra GSI a better buy ? Read more

Ben {P}

Handling refers to how easily a car is to control on the limit.

The term roadholding is used to describe how much grip a car has.

A car can handle very well, but have very little grip and hence only achieve poor lap times. You cannot make a car handle, but you can drive it in a way that takes best advantage of what it can do.


GrahamM

My son has a 1994 M-reg Mondeo GLX 1.8 petrol, which has always been owned by our family from new (my father, me, my son). It's done 136k miles, a lot of it motorway, and been meticulously maintained and serviced. Son now reports a metallic noise from the engine, which garage says is big-ends and will cost about £500, more than the the car's worth. I haven't heard the noise - son lives 150 miles away, but he describes it as a loud metallic pounding. Is it really likely to be b/e at this mileage? Is there anything else (cheaper!) that it might be ?
Many thanks

GrahamM
Read more

Civic8

if it has timing belt be inclined to check it has not slipped,ie valves touching pistons.would be surprised if it is big ends/mains
--
Steve

Manatee

Having just picked up a new car I resolved to RTFM as soon as possible so as not to miss anything. I had almost lost the will to live after 70 pages on seat belts and airbags, ditto 11 pages on how to change a wheel, but the really interesting stuff like how 'Vehicle Stability Assist' works is glossed over in 3 pages (which can be summarised as "leave it switched on".

I guess they are covering the user operation (fair enough) and product liability angles, but I really would like some more info - on VSA for example, which wheels are braked and under what circumstances (it says not all of the braking system is under VSA control, whatever that means), and when might I want to turn it off? (it tells me I can but not why I might want to). There's a light that flashes if "unsuitable fuel" is used - I would like to know if it would operate should somebody put petrol in by mistake (which it says "may cause serious damage"), but of course that information is far too interesting to be included.

This is for a diesel CR-V - do all manuals now include the minimum information in the maximum number of pages, or is it just Honda? Read more

DrS

Steady on, boys, or that humourless computer service technician will be calling to kick you in the larynx!

Hawesy1982

Hi all,

I was talking to my Dad about his company car over the weekend, and he asked me to post his question on here as he knows that i use this site and would welcome as many opinions as possible before he makes a decision.

Currently he has the ubiquitous Mondeo TDCi Ghia as a company car, which is coming up to replacement time. As myself and my two brothers all now drive, there is no longer such a need for him to have a Mondeo-sized car in which to cram belongings for family holidays and uni runs etc.

He has worked out that it would be slightly cheaper for him to run his own car, bought 6months-2years old, than it would be to continue with a new company Mondeo.

The replacement car would likely be Focus-sized, with decent bootspace still important, but cabinspace not so much.

It must be diesel (for driving preference) and have not dissimilar performance to his current 130bhp diesel.

He's not really fussed about image - good value is more important.

So far the ideas have been:

New Model Focus TDCi (either 1.6 110bhp or 2.0 136bhp)
Skoda Octavia TDi 140bhp
Mazda 3 Diesel (engine variant?)

Thanks in advance for your opinions Read more

Malcolm_L

If I understand correctly, his preference is to opt out of the company car scheme to make modest cost savings?

Unless a Mondeo is the only option for a company car, why not downsize but still within the company car scheme.
The P11D value for any of your suggested replacements are all less than a Mondeo and will reduce his BIK.

My suggestion would be a Toyota Prius, I appreciate it's not diesel and doesn't have the outright performance of a 130bhp diesel but it's very kind to the pocket as regards BIK.
Reasonable residuals and has the JH seal of approval.

JohnM{P}

Passed two of the new overhead gantry signs on the M4 tonight with '60 - Queue' and then '40 - Queue'displayed. There was no sign of a queue, and the following signs had no message, so I 'phoned up the Highways Agency (on the hands-free). The operator explained that a 'Queue', together with a slower speed, display is triggered when the traffic sensors in the road (so that's what the black diamonds, often with an accompanying photo-electric panel on the verge, are!) ahead detect slowing traffic. This is to avoid bunching (presumably like the M25 signs), and so, of course, if you don't actually encounter the queue, then they weren't incorrect messages, they must have worked...!
Difficult to argue that one, though the traffic was very light tonight and anything slow would have been simply overtaken... Read more

cheddar

I have a sign up outside my house that says "no
vegetarian tigers"
It must work, because a vegetarian tiger has never knocked on
my door.


Vegitarian Tigers, is that like Spearmint Rhinos?

smokie

There's something caught my eye in an auction on this coming Friday. Does the team think that Friday will bring me an extraordinarily cheap price?

I guess it really depends whether it's caught someone else's eye too, but I can't imagine dealers or Joe Public being out in force to buy a car that day...? Read more

mss1tw

No matter. It's not the one I thought it was.

img.photobucket.com/albums/v70/ABYSS_2k/PICT0430.j...g

;-)