My Ferrari was in an accident but I don't trust it to be repaired - can I make the insurer pay out?

I have been unfortunate enough to be involved in an accident. My Ferrari has an agreed value over £200,000 and repairs are circa £90,000 - however I don't want it repairing. I will not have confidence in the car/repairs and feel the insurer should pay me out. Is there anything I can do?

Asked on 10 August 2017 by mark percy

Answered by Tim Kelly
There are a number of options, the third party's liability lies at the repair cost to re-instate the vehicle to it's pre-accident condition. You could demand for it to be a total loss on that basis. It does also depend on whether you are claiming through your own insurer, an accident management company or directly through the third party.

You could contact the third party insurer directly and ask them to buy the car off you at £200,000 to negate the claim for loss of use of another vehicle whilst your vehicle is being repaired. On a £200,000 Ferrari, to provide an alternative vehicle will probably be costing over a £1000 a day. Should they buy your vehicle off you, they can then repair the vehicle in their own time, mitigating hire cost, and sell the vehicle later without it being a total loss. Should they do this, all parties will be happy. The other alternative is have the vehicle repaired, claim for diminution in loss as it will have reduced in value as a result of the incident and, should you still wish to not have the vehicle, sell it.
Similar questions
Someone drove into the back of my car and admitted liability. Can I refuse to let my insurer write off my car?
A post van pulled out in front of me whilst I was driving my coach. I had to stop abruptly, but it was in a narrow road. When she then proceeded to pass me, she scraped the side of my coach. Repairs have...
I was rear ended a few weeks back and the other driver has admitted full liability. The damage to my car didn't look too bad and I had someone come out to take some pictures last week. I've had a call...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car