December 2009

Hector Brocklebank

It has often been said in the motoring press that Mercedes-Benz do not build their cars like they used too; that they are no longer 'over-engineered'. I'm intrigued to know exactly what is meant by this and if there is a definite point at which one can say that things went downhill. What aspects of bygone Mercedes' were 'over-engineered' and how do they compare to their modern counterparts?

Perhaps there is an element of rose-tinted, 'don't make 'em like that anymore', mindless nostalgia at play? I suppose that someone who has owned numerous Mercs over both eras would be best placed to make a proper assessment?

If Mercs of old are really that good, does a used one make a great buy? Which models are most highly regarded for sheer engineering integrity? Read more

dieseldogg

Ditto for the much maligned Citroen hydropneumatic system. Simple really, if understood.

bostin

Well after 6.5 years and 136k miles, the Passat has reached 200k miles. I think I must have a very mild case of OCD as reaching 200k in a car was in one of those sad list of things to do which I must keep stored in a obscure part of my mind!

Car (B5 TDI 110 sport saloon) bought in June 2003 from a VW dealer on a 97 reg for 7k IIRC. I was the third owner with the previous owner apparently a butcher and giving the car a bit of a hard life - service was 5k overdue when I purchased the car.

Took a little bit of adjusting to a large car in my 20s (I bought the car as the cheapest access to the 110 engine rather than the model) and within a couple of months I'd somehow managed to break the catalytic converter having hit a dip in the road shortly before at a somewhat indecent speed. Fortunately VW stumped up for that repair through the 12 month unlimited mileage warranty. Only other repair in the first year was front suspension arms & related gubbins which were again covered under the warranty.

Once the 12 months were up, I switched to the local indies to keep the car serviced & to change the shocks to Bilsteins. Made a big improvement to the handling. Since that time, the car has been serviced every 10k, with cambelt changes at 120k & 180k. The front suspension has been the only major weakness of the car but if you treat it as a service item then it helps to soften the blow ;-). The climate change module also packed up a couple of years back but was replaced for a couple of hundred pounds IIRC.

Some of you may remember that I have managed to achieve some pretty high mpg out of this car and I'll come back to this. This may give the impression that I have treated the car with the upmost respect & kept it wrapped up in cotton wool. Nothing could be further from the truth! 75% of the time that I've had it, I have let's say, been "making progress". Performance wise the car is not fantastic but at the same time, it's no slouch. 0-60 comes up in just under 11 secs & I've seen 130 (speedo) on the autobahns on one of the many European trips it's been on. Overtakes (of which there have been many) are straight forward with sufficient torque at the important speeds to make things safe. Handling safe but not as dull as described by some.

Coming back to the mpg issue if driven with economy in mind & on roads mainly outside of the south-east, the car has achieved over 1050 miles on a tank which is a little over 75mpg. The car was still capable of achieving such figures a couple of months ago which suggests that the engine is still performing reasonably well. In town & driven hard on motorways, the car will still return 50+ mpg.

The body work is looking a little bit tired now with a few small dents & scratches although these are only really uncovered on its annual (at best) car wash! The bodywork is galvanised and no sign of rust to date. If you take a step or two back from the car, it's my somewhat biased view that the car stands up well in design & look terms when compared to equivalent age cars.

The inside of the car was one of the reasons that I bought the car in the first place. It's now dated but still a fairly pleasant place to be - I'm a sucker for those blue lights ;-). Toys include cruise, climate & trip computer which all still work. The central fan vents adjuster wheels snapped ages ago but I haven't bothered replacing them.

Size wise, it was bigger than our needs when we first bought it. Having said that however at well over 6ft I can sit behind myself comfortably. Now with a toddler in tow, the car is coming into its own & is standing up relatively well to the abuse. The boot is huge although access is limited for larger items.

So, now with 200k up, the question is what do I do now? I had always intended to replace it at this stage (6 years is a record for car ownership for me). However I'm now not so sure! Neither mpg nor performance appear to have made significant advances in the last few years and there appear to be question marks about the reliability of the engine technology to enable these cars to be produced to be in compliance of the emissions regs. The Passat still comfortably keeps up with traffic and matches the mpg. It is currently reliable & covers 20k miles a year. On the other hand, it is due a service (the more major 20k one) and needs four new tyres (I've run Kumho's throughout my ownership of it)....

I've managed to partly satisfy my probably irrational need to have a 'new' car by running an MGF as a weekend toy for the past year. So I'm leaning to stick with what I know but would welcome input from the backroom. What about a halfway house of a B5.5 Passat TDI 130 Estate? Prices seem high for what they are though....

Cheers & apologies for the length of post!

Bost

Read more

LikedDrivingOnce

Top Reply, 659!
I don't know your background (and it's none of my business, anyway), but you talk like someone with inside knowledge of VAG cars.
Do you know if nasties in the current range of Audis, such as the one that you've just described with the six speed gearbox?

llanwrst2

Hi
I have never bought a car before without the advice of my Dad who worked in the motor trade for 40 years. He passed away last year and in 2010 both I and my Mom need to buy nearly new or new (me) and motability (Mom) cars.

My Mom drives a small scooter which I currently get into the back of my Fiat Marea up a small ramp - very easy because it has a drop back and flat entry so I just drive the scooter into the back (riderless - i.e. I drive it from the side of the scooter - hope this makes sence). This car is nearly 9 years old and becoming unreliable as it gets very little use - I want to trade this and my 9 year old Fiat Punto as well - so 2 cars will become one (I cant afford 2 cars anymore!)

We are both looking for small or medium sized estates or hatchbacks with flat entry into the boot - Can anyone help with makes/models that have this? Once I get a few names I can arrange test drives and look at reliability etc but at the moment I cant find anything!

Thank you in advance
Tina Read more

llanwrst2

MAny thanks to all those that helped with the search -and this is the result.......

Mom on the Motorbility scheme unfortunatly opted for a Ford Focus estate - I say unfortunate because the dealer pursuaded her to get the car without trying to get the scooter in first because they did not have one on the forcort to try out!!! Well it will not go up the ramp into the car because there is not enough clearance and the lip is too high. So Mom now dismantles the scooter and has to get a passerby to help her load it in the boot!! - Rubbish!! I'm now trying to get her to go back to Motorbility and get the car changed....

s999srk

Evening,

Does anyone know where the flasher unit is on this car, is it the big orange cube in the footwell fuse box, i know this also function the rear heated windscreen, but could it do both?

Many thanks Read more

elekie&a/c doctor

I would suggest re-check the fuses first.Not too concerned re the scorch marks on the prongs,this is fairly normal,provided the relay base/sockets are not melted.I think you will need to compare your brothers car to determine the exact location of the flasher relay.Listen /feel the clicking relay.There are lots of relay sockets ,some are vacant depending on car spec.hth

Pugugly


***** This thread is now closed, please CLICK HERE to go to Volume 206 *****


In this thread you may ask any computer related question for which you need help, advice, suggestions or whatever.

Usual rules apply,

No motoring related discussion,
No politics,
No Speeding, speed cameras, traffic calming
No arguments or slanging matches
Nothing which we think is not following the spirit of the thread
Nothing that risks the future of this site (please see the small print for details www.honestjohn.co.uk/credits/index.htm )

Any of the above will be deleted. If the thread becomes difficult to maintain it will simply be removed.

There is a wealth of knowledge in here, much of which is not motoring related, but most of which is useful.

This is Volume 205. Previous Volumes will not be deleted.


A list of previous volumes can be found by clicking Here

PLEASE NOTE:

When posting a NEW question, please "Reply to" the first message in this thread, i.e. this one. This keeps each question in it's own separate segment and stops each new question from getting mixed up in amongst existing questions. Also please remember to change the subject header.

Read more

M.M

Thanks all... I'll give those a look in the festive break.

Mazda-Man

I've recently been driving the wife's Focus and found that the AM reception is poor when the engine is running with all sorts of weird interference some of which sounds like some sort of digital interference as opposed to the normal sort of buzzing I've had in the past on old cars with poor aerials. She never uses AM but I like Radio 5 so is there any easy way of improving the reception? The car was bought from a Ford Direct dealer at about a year old and I've no idea if the problem's always existed or something's happened since she got it. Any advice gratefully received as always :) Read more

Mazda-Man

Thanks for that.

Just thought, is the radio supplied with these cars code protected? We've never needed to input a code and don't recall ever getting one when we bought the car so will we to use one if I remove and fiddle around with the unit?

TVM

softopdriver

I know its a bit colder this time of year, but even when I let the car idle for 15 minutes or more the cooling fans do not kick in, even though the temp gauge is well up towards the high end of the scale. On another car I once owned, there was a away to force them on by unplugging a connector and shorting two pins - does anyone know how it could be done on this car?

BTW the car is not overheating at all, i'm just concerned that if and when needed they won't be available as they may have failed or seized. Read more

softopdriver

The Engine and fans are fine your aircon is knackered tho. Probably needs a top
up or it has a leak.


Would low A/C refrigerant cause the compressor to fail to activate then? If so, is it worth getting one of those 'top-up' cans from a motor spares stockist, or better to go for a Kwik Fit type place for a top-up? With the ambient temperatures at the moment, should the compressor still be kicking in when I demand the A/C?
spotop

First of all Hello this is my first post.
I changed the fuel filter and then spent about 3hrs pumping the primer. with no joy. I can hear air going through the the system but no diesel. I removed the filter housing cap to see if any fuel was getting through. But only air. There is a quarter of a tank in. Any ideas could it be the pump?
Cheers. kevin Read more

spotop

That would turn a 2 minute job into something a lot more. The problem we had was the Old primer pump was dead and after the autopsy on it the non-return valve was just floating around inside. And when I had changed it I didn't do a good enough seal. Just get this thing started and then I can relax.

Badwolf

Hello there folks,

Following on from the "Switches and controls you like-dislike" thread, I'd appreciate some advice please.

I have a 2003 Megane Expression and find the automatic wipers fairly infuriating. If it's just spitting with rain, they often flap about the screen like John McCrirrick having a fit and if it's fair chucking down they often stay resolutely still.

I've looked in vain for a way to switch them off and return to good old intermittent wipers but to no avail.

Does anybody have any pearls of wisdom, short of changing the car, please?

Many thanks. Read more

borasport20

I knew it was you, RTB, I just didn't want to out you :-)
sorry about the duff info - I had access to a megane until monday !

atb66

Hi
Earlier this year I bought 56 plate D4D Avensis, 44000k, full Toyota service history - attracted by Toyota reputation for reliability. Since then, now having 2nd new turbo fitted, also a new pump did not fix a steering vibration/noise so a new steering rack going in today (all under warranty). Additionally, engine noisy very when cold, maybe injector noise - dealer says no problem detected.
Am I just unlucky or, as the warranty runs out in January, should I get rid of this car asap? Also, just found out on this forum about head gasket problems with this engine. Does anyone know how widespread this problem is?

If anyone can give me any feedback on any of these issues I would be very grateful.

Cheers Read more

659FBE

I'm still not yet convinced that the Japanese makers have diesel development fully accomplished. The all important fuel systems are generally produced locally under licence from a European designer (often Bosch) with somewhat variable results.

When I see a fully Japanese designed diesel fuel system which has been in trouble-free production for about 5 years, I'll put my money on the table. Until then, if I had a requirement for the model on offer, I'd take the advice given above and buy a petrol engine.

So far, the only makers who have produced some (not all) good small diesels are French or German. As I had a specific requirement for a diesel, I bought a non-DPF VAG PD. So far, I'm very pleased with its performance, economy and reliability. At the time of purchase, it obeyed my "5 year" rule.

659.