Is it fair for an insurer to refuse cover due to a no fault accident?

My 68 year old mother has just purchased a new Fiat 500 to replace a 10 year old Ford KA. Two years ago, while the car was parked in a supermarket car park and my mother was shopping, the KA was hit by another vehicle. She had the accident damage repaired by the other vehicle's owner's insurance company. As a matter of course, she informed her own insurer of the accident and repair. Now when she informed her insurer of her new car purchase, they refused to cover her citing the accident. When challenged, they responded that it didn't matter that the accident wasn't her fault, nor that they incurred no cost. They considered it grounds to refuse coverage and directed her to another insurer who was able to offer cover (albeit it a higher price, though given the car is newer, perhaps understandable). Is this acceptable practice?

Asked on 26 May 2017 by TJ

Answered by Tim Kelly
Every insurer has the right to refuse cover, but considering the risk that your mother is, and the incident, they are clearly being stupid. What you can do is (if they are on the internet) requote using your name but using her details and requote . If they provide a quote and it is less than you have now had to pay, raise a complaint and take to the financial ombudsman. Your insurer has to treat your fairly and cannot penalise you through an incident that is not your fault.
Similar questions
I contacted my insurers to inquire about getting some vandalism repaired on my Range Rover, but it turned out the excess on my policy (which also has protected NCB) was more than the cost of repairs so...
I was recently involved in an accident which wrote off my car. I've notified my insurer without claiming and the third party hasn't claimed either (I suspect she was not insured to drive to begin with...
I got a red light fine but I went to a speed awareness course so assumed I didn't need to declare it to my insurer (Admiral). But they found out and want to charge me £320. What can I do now?
Related models
Funky looks and desirable image. Faithful to original. Easy to drive in town. Suspension improved from 2010.
Easy to drive and economical. Based on the Fiat 500 but handles much better. More room in rear than 500.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car