If a claim has been paid, can the insurer claim it back?

If your insurance has already paid your claim and the money is in the bank, can they then make you pay it back? They are asking for it back because they may not be able to hold the third party fully at fault as there are no witness and a lack of evidence.

Asked on 18 April 2017 by Judith Gaffney

Answered by Tim Kelly
No they cannot. You are dealing with a claim under contract, it does not matter who's fault it is. There need not even be a third party involved, the insurer has to oblige its contract for its insured losses. This may not be the case for your uninsured losses that are not covered in contract. However, if you're dealing with an accident management company or a solicitors, this may not be the case. Make sure you are dealing with your insurer, not someone they have passed you onto.
Similar questions
While parked in a supermarket car park, the rear of my car was hit by a lady driving into to the space to my right. The driver of the vehicle parked in the bay to her right witnessed the accident and I...
I had a no fault accident and my insurance passed me onto an management company, who provided a replacement hire vehicle so I could keep working. Now third party are refusing to discharge the payment....
I've been passed my test just under one year and I've had my new car for three weeks. Last week, I was stationary when someone else hit me from behind. The other driver claimed responsibility straight...

Value my car