Is it safe to buy GAP insurance from a smaller broker for my Land Rover?

When researching GAP insurance I came across on your website. I got a quote from the link and it turned out far cheaper than Land Rover, with what appeared to be similar T&Cs. I have been advised by my Land Rover dealer to steer clear of small brokers selling cheap GAP insurance. Land Rover wants a premium of £968 for a 3-year cover. ALA wants £264. What is your position on this subject?

Asked on 16 November 2013 by AB, via email

Answered by Honest John
Let’s see now. £968 minus £264 is £704 extra commission for the Land Rover dealer and his salesmen over the standard insurance broker commission of about 10 per cent. I wonder whether that could be the reason why they are so keen to sell it to you?
Similar questions
I have just changed my insurance from Churchill to Admiral, via But although obtaining a much lower premium, this was increased by £5.95 because, so I was told, my credit card company Barclaycard...
My car insurance renewal came through last week. I checked on a price comparison website, and found exactly the same policy with the same company, but £53 cheaper. So I cancel the existing policy and take...
I am a retired 73 year old and do around 4000 miles a year maximum. I have protected NCD. When I renew my motor insurance I tell them that I don't need a hire car should mine be off the road (I can use...
Related models
Now has the 3.0 litre V6 diesel engine it really needed. Still unstoppable off-road. Classy image. Refined and high-quality interior. More power and lower emissions from 2012.

Ask Honest John

Value my car