February 2009

David Horn

My sister drove her Xsara (aka my old car) into 3 feet of flood water today. Engine running at tick over, sucked water in and now non-runner. RAC towed it out and it tries to crank a bit but won't turn over.

Clearly water in one or more cylinders. I suspect this is almost certainly a destroyed engine, but has anyone ever heard of an engine recovering from hydrauliccing after the water's been drained out?

It's being dumped back here. Plan is to take out the glow plugs and try to turn the engine over and then change the oil. *Fingers crossed* Read more

David Horn

I wonder how David Horn is getting on with the Xsara?


Don't know yet. RAC bloke decided not to chance the snow and has dumped it at a garage 20 miles away. Not sure whether it's genuinely stuffed (garage haven't called yet) but even if it is, we've decided to go ahead and just stick a second hand engine in.

Dad knows a mobile mechanic who brings his own crane etc.
hillman

Is anybody else experiencing a spurious alarm where the engine warning symbol on the dashboard lights up and the Cruise Control legend flashes without seemingly affecting the running?

The episodes generally last one or two days at a time and then cease. This occurs periodically on my 56 reg Legacy and the garage has made huge efforts over 18 months into trying to find the cause. Read more

hillman

I saw my old neighbours a couple of days ago and remembered the time when we moved into our new houses and started to lay concrete drives etc. His house was opposite mine, and the house was not far from the road and several feet lower. I was very impressed at the care he took to get the profile of the incline from footpath to drive. He made a very professional profile gauge and laid the concrete to it exceedingly well. We were all motoring cheaply in those days he had an old Reliant three wheeler. The path suited the Reliant perfectly. However, we became more prosperous and he came home with a Humber Hawk. ( Does anyone remember those ?). Anyhow, the road clearance of the Humber was much lower and the wheels further apart, and it grounded. I think that the writer of the final scene in ?The Italian Job? got his ideas from the seesawing of the car as my neighbour climbed out. I was at work the next day and never did find out how he got the car back on the road. Read more

ohsoslow

Learned to drive in my father's Hawk in the 60s. Huge black tank of a thing. Once I passed my test I would borrow it for hot dates in return for cleaning and polishing it.

Big full width bench seats..... those were the days!

stunorthants26

Just done a 30 mile round trip in our hire car taking the place of the Sirion while its being fixed, so have some initial impressions. The car was an 07 with 8000 miles.

The car itself is a nice one id say, nice quality, feel solid, rides nicely enough and fairly quiet...
There is a strange issue with road noise though or rather water on the road noise.
When you go through even a small puddle, a noise not dissimilar to running a tap on an empty ice cream tub resonates through the floor and its really very loud - I assume its water hitting the wheelarch linings but I have NEVER come across a car that makes such a racket - my mum said it was louder in the back and to such an extent that she asked me if there was something wrong with the car.

Seats are terrible, very hard and with a strange shape that didnt support my shoulders at all, apparently even worse in the back.
Controls very nicely laid out and easy to find and use, plus attractive to look at.
Boot is a decent size although looking at it, much space is lost to interior coverings as is often the case these days and with a bit of a redesign, it could make a more practical space for a small families belongings. Rear visability isnt great though with a tiny rear window and thick pillars.

The engine is rather nice, gutsy bit not too vocal and gives the car a good turn of speed.
The only real downside is the gearbox - everything negative ive read about these MMTs is so true. It seems to have all the disadvantages of the manual and few of those you get with an auto.
It isnt all that smooth, certainly no better than the box in a Smart, infact its a bit harsher than that as while in the Smart you could adapt to make it drive smoothly, the MMT clonks down the gears and even on the lightest throttle, you still feel the upchange, something that the Smart does better, especially when going down the gears coming to a standstill.
It is also a tad dangerous as takeoff is far from instant, so you need a couple more seconds to jump into a gap in traffic as it just doesnt respond well at all from standstill.
Its fine in normal leisurely driving, but in the cut and thrust of town, it leaves you wishing for a proper auto.
It also has that alarming habit of changing gear just at the times you want it to skirt across a gap and for some reason, on the manual mode, changing up a gear is pull back and change down is push forwards - it didnt feel intuitive at all, seemed the wrong way round to me.

Its only been a brief drive, but my misses has already said its not a patch on her Sirion with its proper autobox and she said why Toyota have given what isnt a bad car, a very inferior solution all in the name of a few mpg is beyond common sense. A CVT would have been far nicer.
If they changed the seats and stuck a decent autobox in it, would make a nice proposition.
Read more

stunorthants26

Misses has just returned from a 250 mile round trip and the economy seems to get alot better - she got 60 odd on that run, so it would appear town work isnt its thing but motorway is, economywise.

rip

Had a new axle fitted to the rear, all fitted fine. The garage replaced the existing brake fluid (dot 4) with dot 5. My car has abs


The brake pedal also feels spongier now (according to some goggling its the silicon that?s in the dot 5 that?s making it do this)

More research shows that it is not compatible with abs systems, is this true and do i ring them and tell them to put either dot 4 or dot 5.1 instead.
Read more

Woodspeed

Yes, if old shoes used (or new for that matter) and it is drum brakes there will be a bedding in period which makes the pedal a little spongy. Should firm up in about 500 miles. Probably the handbrake feels a bit "springy" at the moment too!

suzuki139

hi to all, just new on here and looking a bit of advice. i am looking to buy a passat sport i have heard good reports and very bad reports about the 06-07 models, can someone maybe shed a bit of light on this for me, i dont wont to spend this sort of money to end up having a headic. i would be going for the manual model in this.. any help would be great thanks... Read more

DP

Don't listen to the others they have got something against
VWs. I think it may be envy.


You owe me a keyboard! lol :-)

An 8yr old one won't be the 2.0TDI and will be the old shape. A completely different car to the one the OP asked about.
TimOrridge

Saw this on Calendar earlier, Speechless!

tinyurl.com/bkc7jf

Link made tiny, Rob Read more

mss1tw

I just want to know why he felt the need to hand brake turn it with three lanes to do a turn in. Moron.

ifithelps

This link is to a report of a trial forum members might want to follow.

It's proceeding, so best not to comment until the jury has reached a verdict

news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/7878605.stm

Perhaps the mods would like to make this thread read only. Read more

hj1978

hi all,

i bought a car from a garage back in december which came with a 3rd party 6 month warranty.

i now need to claim on this warranty but the company say there is a £250 limit with a £25 excess.

there is nothing about the limit in my policy document

the warranty was about £160 additional on the price of the car.

thoughts please

cheers Read more

yorkiebar

Good result for you hxj, I hope it sloves the concerns etc.

I think by the warranty company agrreing to pay, they understand too, that they will not be able to force the dealer to pay out.

Best course of action with least stress.

Please understand that I wish the trader had accepted responsibility and sorted it but was trying to prove that he could side step the issue and the SOGA as he has the advantage.

Hope it all sorted out ok!

mikeh81

Hope someone can help

My sister in law has had a low speed impact at the rear of her Aygo, damaging the bumper. She has been quoted £800 to replace, apparently around £200 for parts the rest labour. Does this sound about right?

she is reluctant to claim on insurance despite low excess of £250 because she has run a quote in theory without her 4 yrs no claims and it was £400 more, yes I know she is still better off but thinks in the long term if she can pay less to repair she'd be better off.

Thanks in anticipation Read more

yokel38

the bumper is approx £115, but that is just a plain unpainted, obviously i costs no-where near £700 to paint and fit so I can only assume there is more damage beneath it.