May 2005

tyro

I have a question.

Do the official mpg figures reflect real world experience more closely for some cars (or engines) than for others?

I find that with both my vehicles, the quoted combined figure is remarkably close to what I get in the real world. However, I hear of plenty of drivers who find that they get nothing like the quoted combined figure. This could be due to the way I drive, or the conditions I drive in, of course. (And I sort of get the impression that people with Honda Accord diesel engines don't usually get the mileage they expect, but people with VAG diesels do.)

The most obvious way of testing this is when a driver who regularly keeps a record of fuel consumption changes cars. In most cases the driving style and conditions will remain unchanged, so any large discrepancy would be attributable to the difference between the engines. Read more

Clouddz

I currently get 35MPG in an Isuzu TD engine(not thrashing it or taking it easy) although I have treated with Forte today so we shall see.

THe Growler

Is this yet another piece of pernicious PC-speak drummed up by the inflation-proofed pension seat warmers? You have to hand it to hand to these guys, any opportunity to call a rose by any other name in an effort to justify their joyless overpaid non-productive existence.

It's a bike, a motorcycle, a scoot, a ride, some wheels, but a "powered 2-wheeler?"

Seems like the empty suits can't get past the idea of a 1956 Mobylette or a 2-stroke lawnmower as a m odel for the genre. Even the DT has done it in the Motoring column this week with Mr Ash.

It's beer o'clock here. Time to fire up the Hog, lay some rubber and nip down to the pub for a few brews and revisit the real world....
Read more

ubidenmark

I've had a 2000 A6 quattro from new. It's only done 23K miles and has been religiously serviced throughout its life. I had been hoping to keep it for ten years. Recently it had its 50,000 mile service and came back with an unsolicited "estimate" from the Audi franchise for work apparently required as follows :

1) Replace rear tie bar bushes, worn to excess.
2) Replace secondary sump gasket due to leakage
3) Replace drivers door latch due to activating while driving
4) Replace high level brake light LEDs
5) Replace LAMBDA probes due to no activity in probes

£956 if you please.

I smell a rat. The car was MOTd only a month ago with a LAMDA reading of 0.97. There is no evidence of oil leaking nor any change in the oil level. Most of the brake light LEDs still work. The central locking control unit, I have learned, is located at the bottom of the passenger door cavity - essentially at the bottom of a water tank. It's not surprising if it short circuits so Audi should eat that one.

The other thing that's bothering me is that in addition to the service itself they charged £22 to replace the wiper blades "due to juddering." The old ones were fine. The new ones judder as well. All wiper blades judder on every Audi I've ever had and it may be a coincidence but needless replacement of wiper blades is one of the most notorious swindles perpetrated by garages on unsuspecting punters.

What it seems to amount to is that on every item that can be independently verified the garage is wrong. And on everything that can't be checked by me they're saying "trust us."

Am I being taken for a mug ?



Read more

No Do$h

Thanks for the follow up and glad this site, amongst others, has been of help to you.


No Do$h - Alfa-driving Backroom Moderator
mailto:moderators@honestjohn.co.uk

MapReader

Hi All

First post here, so please be kind.

I had a v.scary blow out today, just as I was turning left off a v.busy road, then the brakes gave up, couldn't make the turn (it was sharp) so had to get back onto the main road going over one of those island thingies in the process. Nearly scared me half to death. The spare wheel has been attached (thanks to a very VERY kind passing lorry driver) and I drove home, albeit carefully, in case the brakes were to fail again.

My questions: Did the brakes fail because the wheel blew out....or is it more likely that the brakes failed first then the wheel got ruined when I hit the kerb of the island? The brakes did re-engage when I straightened up, and were OK on the 2 mile drive home. Should I be suspect of the brakes now, ie if I take the car on the road am I actually taking a big gamble with it?

NB it was serviced about six weeks ago, and new calipers were fitted just before Christmas.

Any advice on the car's roadworthiness (just to get to a garage) would be most welcome.

Also, any opinions on getting a new wheel from a scrapy...good idea or bad idea? It's five year old Fiesta.
Read more

sierraman

If the servo failed you would notice straight away,the brakes would be so ineffective you would be grabbing for the handbrake.

smoking motor

This has Probably been answered some where already but can find it?
I have a p-reg 306 D-turbo and the tacho seems to cut in and out when ever it feel like it when it works it read rpm correctly it been like this since june last year. I think It one of three things

The hall sensor need to be taken out and cleaned No idea how to remove the weather cap without damaging it.

The wire from hall sensor has a fualt same problem again

There is a loose earth connecting somewhere in the dash again no idea where this connection is, Evey time you touch the brake the clock autodims.

Or the is a dodgy relay in the tachometer circuit if there is one i have looked in the hayne fairly tail manual to find out info on how to fix these problems to no avail.

Could do with feed back from some one with experienace. I would like to dianosed it first before spending money on an auto electrician.

Also can someone recmended me a good rear wiper blade that clean the whole window inside of missing the top with out streaking.
Triple blade type no idea what they are called though

Cheer for some help if any
Read more

solara

The intermittent tacho is very likely to be a dodgy inductive pick up sensor, on the flywheel (TDC sensor). This is common on old 306 diesels. Replacement TDC sensor costs about 25 quid from a pug dealer. Make sure you get the right one, as there are different ones for each engine type.
If you want to test it, you will nees an oscilloscope to check the pulse output (in the order of millVolts).
Replacing it is fairly easy, if you have access underneath eg pit or hydraulic ramp. Simple 3-pin plug connector near fuel filter area.
Bend your wiper blade to shape, so it fits snug up the top. Rear windscreen is not flat, so bend it to fit.

johnny

Depending on which way I'm parking (and it's not a particularly steep camber ) my fuel gauge seems to vary about by a quarter of a tank. It also takes about five minutes to level out on the flat. Is this typical of Vauxhalls or is there some kind of damper mechanism that's getting stuck? Read more

David Horn

Typical of all cars, I imagine. The damping only has effect when you're driving the car and the fuel is sloshing about and remainging, on average, parallel to the ground. When parked up, the fuel settles on one side of the tank and hence you get a false low. The damping is working fine, which is indicated by the fact it takes 5 minutes for the gauge to level out.

Might also be your level sensor is at one side of the tank, so when you park on a particular camber the fuel is nearly all over the other side of the tank and away from the sensor. I wouldn't worry about it, the fuel gauge on my Astra used to change going around roundabouts.

cockle {P}

While reading the threads 'advice needed over court decision' and 'obscured vision from junctions' it occured to me that road traffic accident investigation principles seem to be contrary to other forms of accident investigation.

To me, at least, RTA's seem to be investigated on the basis of looking for fault to apportion blame. Is this due to the confrontationary nature of insurance and also the need to provide evidence for court in the event of an offence having been committed? If so I feel great opportunities are being missed to improve road safety which the current approach certainly seems to be failing to achieve.

In most other walks of life, aircraft accident investigation, workplace accidents, etc. the investigation is designed to provide evidence if an offence has been committed but its primary function is to discover cause. Once cause has been established recommendations are then made as to try and prevent a reoccurence of the same type of accident.

I always ask myself the question when people refer to 'blackspots', if it is known why is something not done to prevent it recurring? I know the answer is going to be financial but with true costs of even minor injury accidents, let alone fatals, running into ten of thousands of pounds apart from personal misery surely it would become cost effective.

As an example, a local dual carriageway suffered three fatal crossover accidents before money was found to put crash barriers in. If the barriers had gone in after the first, or even second accident, not only would three people still be alive but the medical, police and court costs saved would probably have paid most of the cost of the barriers.
Just seems daft to me that we don't investigate properly and put remedial measures in place in a timely fashion.
Cockle Read more

NowWheels

I dont get this bit. ANyone care to expand a little on this point please?


As well as Bromptonaut's useful point about the different standards of proof required for criminal prosecution and civil liability, consider this situation.

We are driving in opposite directions on a single carriageway road. I have a front tyre blowout, lose control, and swerve onto your side of the road, crashing into you. Subsequent investigation reveals that it wasn't due to lack of maintenance, just a freak failure of the tyre.

I crossed the white line drove into you, so I'm liable for the damages. But no criminal offence.

(I'm sure there are better examples, but hope that helps).
Armitage Shanks {p}

Is the Ferrari F1 team self-supporting, thru sponsorship, named watches and clothing etc or do people who buy the roadcars pay £???? per car to help fund the racing operation? Read more

Cardew

Dont forget all the prize and appearance money they get from
the FIA. This is quite a substantial amount. Also, the sponsors
have to pay an awful lot to Ferrari. I think Marlboro
pay in the region of £30m to be title sponsor. I
wouldn't think Vodafone will be too far behind this figure.
It is now believed in some quarters that they are only
the 3rd or 4th biggest spenders in F1 now. Toyota are
rumoured to be number 1, and then comes McLaren and possibly
Williams if you take into account all the money spent by
Mercedes and BMW on their engines.


In many countries if you asked all but the most enthusiastic follower of F1 who McLaren and Williams are' they wouldn't know. Their cars are simply known as Mercedes and BMW.
Roly93

I'm about to change the front tyres on my car, and have been looking around at what to get. Currently I have Conti Sport Contact II's fitted, and I noticed on the web that these come in a V and W speed rating ie 205/55/16 91W fitted to the car now.

However, there is a huge difference in price between the V & W spec tyres.

Given that both speed ratings are well in excess of the cars capabilities, why shouldn't I just go for the lower V rating ?

Comments please. Read more

cheddar

V rating is 149 mph, assuming your car cannot get within 10 mph of this then check with a main dealer then inform your insurer, you will have covered you bases.

It is true to say that engine torque and braking loads are a factor in specing tyres however I went through the same dilema, checked with the relevant parties and no problem.

Armitage Shanks {p}

This makes interesting reading, or not, depending on your viewpoint!

A Black Country motoring menace has been ordered to stay off the roads AGAIN after clocking up his 21st driving ban at the age of 26 - while riding a mini motorbike.

Car-mad Richard Lawley, of New Town, Brockmoor, Brierley Hill, admitted his 32nd offence of driving while disqualified to take his tally of criminal convictions to more than 170.
Read more

Dynamic Dave


Thread locked as the conversation has headed more toward judge, jury & conviction, than anything to do with motoring.

DD.