November 2004

Felix

I need something cheaper to run than my current 5-series, without giving up too many creature comforts, looking to spend not too much over £10k (11 at a push). I've been looking at the options among 1-2 year old diesels and my shopping list's shrunk down to 2 (an odd couple you might think): a Megane hatch 120 DCi Privilege or a Mondeo TDCi Ghia (or maybe Zetec) 115 or 130PS. I've been given derisory spins around the block by dealers and both seemed very nice, lovely smooth engines with lots of mid range urge, and the Megane's handling seemed better than I'd been led to believe.

I know that if I want a Mondeo Ghia for the price of the Megane, I'd be looking at a pre-facelift model with a few more miles on the clock. Also I don't really need a car as big as the Mondeo, there just don't seem to be many smaller diesels around that offer that kind of refinement. I've read lots about how cheap the Mondeo is to run, but I was amazed to find cost per mile figures in What Car showed the Mondeo at 49p and the Megane at only 34.

I know I'm comparing apples with oranges here, but I really don't know which one to go for. Can anyone help me decide?

Thanks! Read more

runboy

malcy b

Thanks for the info. I'm still in two minds. Looks like I have tough decision ahead of me!

Dynamic Dave


**** Poll closed. ****


This weeks poll, as suggested by Tom Shaw is now available.

"Have you ever driven uninsured?"

Deliberately.
Mistakenly.
Never.

Read more

Robin Reliant

My reason for suggesting the question was that a few years ago I bought a new bike from a dealer just before going on holiday. I didn't want to leave it at home while away as I didn't have a garage at the time so he agreed to keep it till I came back. I sorted the insurance and arranged to pick it up the day we got back, but with a two week gap overlapping a month I cocked up the dates, and it wasn't till I got home with the bike and was sorting the paperwork that I realised the insurance didn't start till the following day.

Would have been an catastrophic mistake had I had an accident or got a routine pull, as 6 points minimum would have meant end of career for no longer being a fit and proper person to remain a driving instructor.

BobbyG

Along the same lines as what came first, the chicken or the egg, I ask - what came first, the bus lane or the congestion?

For a couple of years I have sat here smugly at the computer in my wee village in Scotland, reading about all the complaints of bus lanes, congestion etc and rejoicing in the fact that my work is 20 mins away, on the motorway and I can park in the car park of the store.

Unfortunately, I am now working in Edinburgh for a couple of months and, oh my God, i just could not put up with this on a daily basis! Instead of travelling time of 40 mins per day, I am lucky to be less than 2 and a half hours!

Anyway, to get to the point, if I leave work at 3.50pm, I can do the 5 mile stretch of urban road through Edinburgh City Centre in as little as 7 to 8 mins.

However, when the bus lane opens at 4pm, and I leave work at 4.10pm, it can take me up to 35 mins to do the same 5 miles!!
Yes, the traffic will be a bit heavier but I can't help but think that this is purely down to the fact that the traffic is only on one lane.

I know this is what the traffic planners want to prevent cars in the city (David Begg was originally from Edinburgh), but I just can't help but think if there were no bus lanes the traffic would be so so much better.

So going back to my original question, are the bus lanes the cause of the congestion, or the solution? Read more

Altea Ego

To get people on buses you have to make them appear better than cars. That usually means faster in a given situation. Now you cant make buses faster, in fact you slow them down by doing away with routemaster types and having a single crew who has to drive and take money.

So what do you do? you slow car traffic down.

Lucian Deville

Hi

I'm thinking of buying a brand new automatic for Mrs D.

Criteria:

1:Max RRP 16k - We are assuming we will get a big discount, so the cheaper the car the better!

2:Must have a 5 start NCAP

3: Has to be as high as the Ford fiesta, or higher for that commanding driving position.

4: No bigger than the ford focus, Or smaller than the MB, A class.

5: Must be very reliable.


6: At least a 12 year corrision warranty.

7; Good handling.


Of course you don't have to justify every question - the important answer we are looking at is the most reliable aut/cvt box.


Thanks in advance

Lucian Deville Read more

Lucian Deville

thank you all - we have got the brochures on the Verso - good all round and crash rating, a bit to big, we think?

Re the Audi - good car, never been in an A3, but did have an A4 - I feel that we will not get the commanding driving positon in the audi.

Thanks for all of your ideas/help - all apreciated.

LD

Lucian Deville

Hi

Most will be aware that we have the company that carrys out the car crash tests and gives the car upto 5 stars and 37 points max.

The Americans have their own version.

My query is, why are the tests not carried out on rear impacts?? This is a very important part of the safety feature, specially if you are rear ended on a motorway when you are stationary in traffic.

Another query, why are manufatures allowed to put seats in cars and MPV's right up against the rear window?? Can you imagine someone sitting in a MPV against the rear window and an impact from a lorry at 30mph??

Thanks in advance!!

Lucian Deville Read more

Lucian Deville

>>100%, doesn't that mean that a rear seat passenger would never

be seriously injured?
I think if a car receives an impact from behind, or
at the rear from any angle, then the chances of a
rear seat passenger being seriously injured, or killed, would be a
fair bit higher than for anyone in the front.




Hi

Rear seat passenger reminder is a good thing.

EG: If HRH Princess Diana had been wearing one - we are certain she would of survied the crash.

Regards

Lucian
Miller

Oh well, I wont bother crashing into the back of your car then!

Surely the most preposterous car sticker in existence? Read more

madux

We have a "Working dog", - never done a day's work in his life, lazy git.
I like the sticker "If you can read this you are driving too close"

henry k

Car number plate camera trials see 13,500 arrested
By Philip Johnston, Home Affairs Editor The Daily Telegraph

Thousands of motorists stopped by police using number plate recognition scanners have been arrested for a range of non-driving offences.

David Blunkett, the Home Secretary, said the success of the new Automated Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) cameras was such that he was extending the scheme.

An extra £15 million would be spent equipping the police with the system, which is used by half the forces in England and Wales. Figures published yesterday showed that in a 12-month pilot period in 23 force areas there were nearly 13,500 arrests for a wide range of offences.

The Home Office said the arrest rate was nine times the national average. Police intercept teams stopped 180,000 vehicles using the system. They recovered 1,152 stolen vehicles worth more than £7.5 million, stolen goods worth more than £640,000 and drugs valued at £380,000.

Officers also recovered 13 firearms and 266 offensive weapons. There were 3,330 arrests for driving offences, 2,263 for theft and burglary, 1,100 for drug offences and 1,300 for vehicle theft.

The cameras can check up to 3,000 vehicles an hour. Mr Blunkett said ANPR was "a powerful tool" that brought enormous benefits to the police and to society.

The system works even if the targets are travelling at 100 mph. The infrared digital cameras can capture images, even in poor light, rain, reflection or dazzle. Computer software reads the number plates and sends the information to databases that can alert officers within seconds to stolen, unregistered, untaxed or uninsured vehicles.

Most drivers are stopped for failure to display a tax disc or for talking on a mobile phone and are given a £30 fixed penalty.

For more serious offences, such as driving without insurance, £200 endorsable penalties can be issued but the research showed that only 14 per cent of these were paid.

The report said there was evidence that penalties in court were sometimes less severe than the fines themselves, encouraging offenders not to pay the on-the-spot fine and go to court instead.

Read more

tr7v8

They had it set up just after J6 ACW M25 last year with very visible police van & mobike & cameras in each lane. The Traffic slowed at around J10 and crawled all of the way because every muppett decided to go under it at around 30MPH. The queues were absolutely horrendous. And I could have quite happily strangled whoever had sanctioned it. Could have been done much more covertly and caused far less problem. But keeping traffic moving these days isn't a high priority.

Jim

tyro

With reference to recent Back Room polls on the priorities of BRs when buying a new car, I asked my wife what her priorities were. One of the top things on her list was "good brakes" - which seems pretty reasonable to me.

But how does one find out which models have good brakes? We've got NCAP scores to tell us which cars come out best when we can't stop, but I'd rather know which car did best at stopping. Car mags have plenty of tables that give us 0-60 figures, but not 60-0 figures. Read more

Baskerville

>The worst apart from any fully powered citroen system which are pointless

The fully powered Cit system gives phenomenal braking performance though; so good in fact that it takes some time to get used to after ordinary cars, but when you do it is hugely reassuring. Combined with abs in the BX it was truly wonderful. One big advantage of the old Citroen system was that it allowed variable brake distribution between front and rear brakes depending on load--more braking to the rear wheels if you have passengers on board. This was available on all hydropneumatic models as far back as the 1950s. Of course now we have electronics to do all this for us, and with more subtlety too, but Citroen's system was clever, simple, and very reliable.

AndrewMarc

I am contemplating buying a ka that has been in a garage for 6 months. it was not prepared for storage. I am taking it to a garage to get it on the ramp but will he be able see problems due to this and will these problems be expensive(I am gettin a good deal so can afford to spend 500-700 quid) Read more

madf

As mentioned above plugs can rust in. A drop of oil around the threadss where they enter the block should prevent that: no need to remove plugs.

Do that with son's 1.1 Fiesta 1993: always easy to remove.

madf


helicopter

My Company Vecra 2 litre Diesel is an R reg and has only done around 17000 miles.

I had a problem with it being very sluggish a few months back , (see www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?t=17875 for details) I asked the question on here and the MAF sensor was replaced which seemed to cure the problem although accelleration was never comparable with my own Civic.

Basically it has started the same problem again. The engine management light started flickering on and off for a minute or so after starting and then went out.

Yesterday the sluggishness returned and then on M23 the EML light came on and I was hard pressed to get 60mph. I got to my destination and when I got in to return home I switched on the ignition and the EML had cleared and the drive was better though still not right.

A possible factor is an electrical fault - I have noticed that the screen display for time , radio station name etc is not functioning correctly with gaps everywhere.

I would appreciate any suggestions as to likely causes before I go to the garage. Read more

DL

These older Vx diesels seem to be giving a bit of trouble nowadays - perhaps one to avoid, perhaps?
--
groups.msn.com/honestjohn - Pictures say a thousand words.....