May 2003

Amin_{p}

Just a quick note. Wasn?t it really embarrassing that on the national IQ test, mechanics lost to body builders and had the lowest average IQ out of all the six groups and it was 8 below the average IQ???? Something seriously went wrong there (I am thinking on the lines of where they did they get those mechanics from?!?)?? Still makes you think twice next time you ask your mechanic?s opinion on why the engine diagnosis light is doing a samba on the dashboard?? Read more

RichieW

They have, but they are honest enough to mention that the articles in question are sponsored by the relevant brands first.

Amin_{p}

Hi again. A question on brakes please. I acquired my third AX !!!(soon my front drive will turn into a Citroen memorabilia fair with bits of AX hanging everywhere). I got the said the car for 50 quid and its almost perfect. Done 70k, and the owner had to get rid of it as he bought a new car and the tax on this one had finished and he didn?t have a drive. Anyhow, the car has a brake problem which I am hoping your wisdom will help me to solve in the shortest time. (by the way those who helped with me with my other AX?s gearbox, thanks, done what was said and its better now). On this one, I have to apply the brakes considerable harder than my other two AX to stop the car. First thought was worn pads, checked them, almost new. Checked the fluid, no leaks. Checked the cables, nothing slack. I was puzzled until I realised two things. First if I `pumped? rather than just press as hard as I could, then the brakes worked better, second it seemed only the front left wheel and the rear right wheel are providing much of the stopping power (when I braked hard on a wet road, these two wheel locked up). I then jacked up the back and realised that rear left wheel fail to stop at ALL when either the brake pedal is pressed or the handbrake fully pulled. I mean even with the hand brake fully pulled and someone pressing the brake pedal I can turn the wheel by my hand. So my question is, what are the likely chances of a single problem being related to both these issues? What could that be? And could that also be responsible for the over all lack of any braking force? Could just a worn shoe lining be responsible for all this? Or has a circuit failure happened somewhere? Or I can?t tell until I open the rear brake drum (which I will do the coming weekend)? Read more

Amin_{p}

Well the drum came off, and as always it was a surprise, in fact the surprise was nothing, there was nothing wrong in there!!! Actually what I thought was one problem which caused all those symptoms, turned out to be several problems which incidentally looked like they were related. As far as the handbrake went, the cable had rusted inside the outer casing and had snapped right before it went into the drum, so in fact although when I was pulling the lever I felt some resistance, it wasn?t pulling the shoes, it was the force of the outer case ballooning up. As for the Brakes, the problem was as far as I can see due to severe neglect of the car. I am not sure, but this is what I think happened. At some point in the past, the master cylinder had gone and one of the circuits had failed. I could check this because little oil was reaching the cylinder. I thought it might be just the piping, but I checked at the master and it wasn?t much coming out of there either. The vacuum assist was working and seal was fine as no hissing could be heard. Anyhow, the owner had obviously carried on using the car with this fault and somehow the back cylinder seized up due to rust (because the circuit had failed and they weren?t moving), then the neglect continued and rust developed on the pipes just after the flexible bit (when the pipe comes from the front, there is a section of flexible tubing so that the pipe can sit on the rear axle before it goes into the drum). Somehow from this, air was being sucked into the system but oil was no leaking out. Because the car is not loosing oil, but every time you de-air the system, it comes back. I don?t think it?s the master, because air is trapped only before one of the rear cylinders (the wheel that was not braking). Anyhow, what I thought would be a simple fix, has turned out to be major repair due to some persons neglect of the car. It is amazing how many people think a car is just a `machine? and don?t realise it almost has a life if its own and if you don?t take care of it, it will die. In this case a simple neglect of a faulty cylinder which cost 10 quid, damaged the entire system. Anyhow now I am faced with a complete new brake system, including a master cylinder, real cylinders, and new piping, plus the handbrake cable. So there you go. pink fluffy dice happens, but that?s life!!!

DavidHM

A friend of mine got drunk one night, totalled his car and was appropriately convicted about two years ago. He is now looking to start driving again, and while he knows that insurance premiums are going to be high (£1200 for a Cinquecento) the car wasn't insured in his name. As a result, it was his father who made the claim, with my friend as a named driver.

They paid out and all is fine there. He wants to know whether, in response to the specific question which is usually phrased "Have you had any claims in the last n years" (my emphasis) should he say yes, or given that it was his father who filled in the claim form, can he gloss over this?

I know there is a general duty to inform an insurance company of anything that may be relevant to calculating a premium, so it may be a moot point - but what do these questions actually mean? Read more

RichardW

>The £1200 is an actual quote based on both the claims and the convictions. It is only TPF&T on a group 1 car, but it is also for a 25 year old in London, with Direct Line.

I stand corrected... That's pretty cheap considering!

Richard

Yoby

Dad advertised his Vauxhall Corsa in local newspaper - didn't expect a lot of response - thought he would have to drop the price over the coming weeks. Not a bit of it - at least 3 people interested. Final bloke offered near enough asking price saying he based his purchase decision on Dad appearing a friendly, honest & down to earth person!

Gave me a kinda warm feeling when Dad told me!!

Bit of a cheesy story I know .... but thought I would share it!

Yoby Read more

DavidHM

lol, fair enough, I wouldn't be surprised if the insurance contract was drafted so narrowly that you had to get both events, in that order, before it woudl pay out.

Oh and Blue, no, he doesn't know quite how bad the deal is. If he'd shopped around, for the amount of money he's paid, he could have had a new shape Vectra 3.2 on an 02 plate with 12k on the clock.

Grizzled Chris

I would be interested to hear any points of view which might help our choice of family transport. We have four strapping school age children and like to go camping. I don't want to use a trailer on holiday and we also need plenty of space for day to day in term time.Our choices seem therefore to be limited to the Caravelle or the Previa. They are both good vehicles, but which to choose? We have to buy second hand, and we like to keep our cars for as many years as possible.
Does anyone have any experiences they'd like to share about their ownership of these vehicles, such as fuel consumption, servicing costs, reliability and resale value at the end?
Thanks, Grizzled Chris.
Read more

mark999

You could also consider the mercedes V-class if you can put up with the terrible reliability.
I have just sold my v-class and have bought a Caravelle Tdi.
First impressions of the caravelle are that it is more of a van than the V class, and not as plush inside. The brakes and handling are much better however.

derek

hi i am thinking of buying a friends higher mileage car
it'll be a 2.0 dti vectra estate 51 plate with around 100000 miles on the clock it wil go for 2-2500 in about 12 months time
it will have been used as his company car and serviced when it should be. it carries tools of his trade and that sort of thing
i already have an n reg vectra with 53000 on it and for what i paid (1850) it seems ok we are happy with it.
ive never bought a high miler before and always bought privately where i can.
i know what to look for , im just wondering what everyone elses views on higher mile cars are??? is it worth a chance ? what are other readers experiences??
many thanks derek. Read more

Amin_{p}

mileage is not completely independent of the condition of the car. some parts are clearly used more as the mileage rises. For example bearings (which wear and become loose), steering mechanism (loose track end rods..), and several parts of this type whose wear and tear is not related to `how' you drive the car. On the other hand, some parts are related to how you drive the car, these include driveshaft (if you are a nutter and accelerate with spinning wheels round a corner, then bye bye CV joints), clutch, gear box (the screeching noise when you change gear in a haste and which rounds up 1 mm of the ill-fated gear) and other such parts. Therefore if you want to get a high mileage car, always check that in addition to it having had the service (cam belt is crucial) that it was not driven by a nutter. I have three AXs, one of them is a J reg which has done 140K and one of them is a H reg which has done 70K. the H reg one has better suspension (dampers in better shape), steering feels much better and the car rattles much less and its all due to the low mileage, although the car is older (both are 1.4 5 door). on the other hand the H reg used to be owned by a `boy racer' and so some parts of the car are knackered. the clutch slips, the CV joints are gone, the gearbox is about to go, the engine is completely abused (mainly due to `take offs' at traffic lights) and other problems of this sort. The J reg on the other hand was owned by a father of two who had passed his hormonal overdrive period, and so even though it has done twice the mileage, it is still on the original clutch and it feels perfect, the shafts don?t knock about and the gearbox is as smooth as a Galaxy milk chocolate bar. But because of the high mileage, the wheel bearing are slack, the steering knocks a notch, dampers are about to meet their after life and the car rattles much more. So in the end, mileage is neither completely independent nor completely the only factor on how good a car is. It depends on

1) who the driver was (this is more important as far I am concerned, than if the service book is up to scratch, you can always replace a battery that was supposed to have been replaced, but if you end up with an abused engine, you have had it)

2) servicing - specially oil change, belt change..

3) how did the mileage come about (motorway miles are less damaging than city miles obviously. my J reg AX has a lot of miles because it was used to travel from Oldham to London regularly.

4) sometimes when you test drive a car which you have not driven before its difficult to say anything about it based on how it feels, because you don't know how it is `supposed' to feel. (like first time you test drive a diesel car..). the best way I have found is to test drive at least two cars of the same model you are interested, and this given you a very good idea of the feeling of the car you are about to buy relative to how its supposed to feel.

howy686

When reversing my wife's 106 (1124cc petrol '96P at 42000 miles) touching the brakes produces a distinct thud from the front. It must be bad - even she's noticed it. (Sorry - unnecessary chauvenistic remark!!).
Seriously though - it's more distinct on left lock and doesn't show up by applying forward/reverse drive - only reverse braking.
Steering feels OK although maybe there is a slight knock over big potholes.
I've used a lever (carefully) on every bush and joint I can see and the caliper bolts are not loose - any ideas would be welcome. Read more

greaser pv

Take a breaker bar with socket to fit wheel nuts , put socket on one nut and with bar at 90% check movement forwards and backwards whilst applying gradual force, you may find there is excessive movement one way or another, suspect rear lower arm bushes.

FergusTheDog

I have been trying the A4 Cabriolet. Alas still 2wd in RHD but nice all the same. The V6 TDi is a very odd handler. It weighs 122 Kg more than the 1.8T that has the same bhp and it is clearly all under the bonnet (where else could it be?). Definitely needs a stiffer front end to stop it wallowing and something needs to be done to stop it running wide.

The 2.4 petrol is slower than the 1.8T and is very lethargic. The 3.0 litre petrol seems to be the best sorted by some distance but it's pretty thirsty.

All in all, just not sure. Anyone else out there tried one? Read more

Forum Cars on TV
Morris Ox

Just been watching one of the numerous house programmes on TV(Channel 4's Selling Houses) and noticed the camera lingering for rather a long time on the Peugeot 607 driven by the presenter.

If you watch Location, Location, Location you'll see them do the same with a Volvo XC90.

Not really bothered about a debate about the pros and cons of soft marketing, but it got me thinking once again about the long, chequered relationship between cars and TV.

Everybody has their favourite, but for my money you can't beat VHK 741S, a Granada which used to appear on The Sweeney back in the 1970s.

And if you don't agree with me, then in the words of Jack Regan...shut iiit!

Read more

Ian (Cape Town)

>> Blues Brothers:
>> \" It\'s got a cop motor of four hundred and forty
>> cubic inch plant, it\'s got cop tyres, cop suspension,
>> cop shocks,
>> it was a model made before catalytic converters so it\'ll
>> run good on regular gas. What do ya say, is it the
>> new Blues Mobile or what?\"
To which Jake replied:- \"Fix the cigarette lighter.\"


Problem solved, Growler:
\"We are in pursuit of a \'74 Dodge sedan, with Illinois plates.\"
Sad, or what?
jonesy127 {P}

With a budget of £5000, I want (obviously) an economical car, but at the same time a fun car - decent acceleration and a nice chassis.

Comfort and safety are important too, so I want dual airbags, air con and abs. In fact, any feature beginning with A would be good!

Oh and I don't want a 'birds' car. C'mon people, you know what I'm talking about.

Any ideas? I don't want much, do I? Read more

andymc {P}

Oops, 143 bhp not 145, my mistake. Yes, it'll be easier to get a 1996 model for £6k, but I found several for less than that on a national search on the Autotrader site, some 1995, some 1996, entering "tds" as a keyword when searching for 525's. As for quality, just give it a thorough inspection as per HJ's How To Buy & Sell Cars (BTW, thanks for all the tips HJ!)and do a HPI and you should be fine. I had the slower version, the TD, which I got in November for £3900 and sold for £4100 in March.