October 2002

CMark {P}

Hi All,
Having read some high quality technical input on this forum, I?d like to pick everyone?s brains on an issue that is vexing me but one you probably haven?t come across before: that of running modern car engines on LEADED fuel.

Background

Here in Jordan almost all the second-hand cars imported into the country are sourced from Europe (Germany provides 75% of total, mostly BMWs and Mercs) or the USA, i.e. are catalyst equipped. However, you can only get UNLEADED fuel at a few fuel stations here in the capital, Amman. UNLEADED is simply not available at all outside the capital. So most people just fill up with the 4 star or 2 star that is widely available and cheaper than unleaded to boot. Crazy government policy, I know, and this is before we get into the discussion of the total prohibition of diesel-engined passenger cars and station wagons!

After a while, most cars suffer a significant performance drop which is normally resolved simply by sawing off the now-blocked catalyst?(The all-too-true joke goes: You can give a [insert Third World nationality] a brand new, top-of-the-range car and he?ll bu66er it up in two weeks but keep it going for 30 years?) Anyway?

My question is:

What are the long-term effects of running cars designed to use UNLEADED on leaded fuel? Either in general terms or vehicle specific.

Issues to consider might be: fuel injection system, ECU control of timing, combustion temps, combustion chamber materials, spark plugs, Lambda sensor. Some vehicles have an additional sensor in the catalyst itself ? what happens when that is removed/ disconnected (apart from a dashboard light coming on)?

A subsequent issue is that of the removal of the catalyst itself and the subsequent change of exhaust backpressure that may have a detrimental effect on engine longevity. What effect might this have on exhaust valve temperature?

Whilst most interested in people?s opinions, I am also looking for research papers and test results, both lab-controlled and any owner?s experiences.

Of course, much has been written about using UNLEADED in old LEADED-spec engines e.g. valve seat and ignition timing issues. Looking for answers to my question I have spent many an hour with search engines, but as yet to no avail. Here is where any web whizzos might be able to help. Obviously, there is not going to be a huge amount of info to answer my question, as it is not relevant to most car users. But I would hope that somewhere there might be something useful or interesting.

The reason I would like this information is that many of my acquaintances know I am an automotive engineer so I get constantly asked for advice on this one. Until now, I can only offer second-hand anecdotal evidence, which I will gladly offer if anyone is interested.

I would be delighted to discuss this at length on email wilson@nol.com.jo

Sorry for the long post and I hope someone can help,

CMark
"Don't tell him, Pike!"
Read more

John S

CMark

Interesting. Confirms the info. I have that it's not just the cat etc that need to be removed from engines to make them suitable for leaded. Sounds like there are mechanical differences too.

Regards

John S

SjB {P}

As a keen biker myself, I have today received a 455KB .mpa (movie) file that shows - very amusingly - what can go wrong when you show off with your mates. I say amusing, but actually I nearly split my sides laughing!

I don't have any web space of my own to publish it on for your benefit, and don't want to go through the hassle of creating some that I don't otherwise need, so would HJ or anyone else be willing to receive the file from me for this purpose?

Cheers,
Steve Read more

Paul Mykatz-Tinks

Thanks, Cyrill, works now.

Good 'un and, yes, it is on
www.punchbaby.com
This one is a bit longer (under "ouch" if I remember correctly).

There's a lot more there as well.....you'll like the one called "pullUp"

I know these things.................

ta5gdu

Rover 220 Coupe N Reg 96 2.0L DOHC Engine

Problem:

Engine cuts out when the car is in traffic (idling for long time after long runs) and won't idle until temperature under the hood drops.

I've tried disconnecting the following to determine a problem:

Lambda Sensor
ATS
CTS
TPS
Idle control stepper motor

Changed fuel relay, HT Coil, rotor arm and lead to distributor.

Rover dealer had the car for a week and found no problem but tightened an earth connection. Problem returned the next hot day.

Really stratching my head now and would appreciate any help.


Read more

aaron

Yesterday someone low-speed bumped my car whilst it was parked outside my house, causing significant damage to the rear bumper (colour coded etc.). They got out of their car, inspected the damage and then drove off. My neighbour got their reg. number, swept up their broken glass etc.
Does anyone know what my chances of tracking them down and exchanging insurance details? Should I report the incident to the police? Should I report it to my insurance company (even with £250 excess I'll need to make a claim if I have too) and expect my legal expenses cover to handle tracking them down and getting a claim on their insurance?
Needless to say I am a bit wound-up about this!
Cheers
Aaron
Read more

Dwight Van Driver

So Aaroon,

What did you do?

DVD

Forum 70+mph
Edd

I hope someone out there can help me . On the way home today I decided that I want to see how fast and how well my car handles at high speeds. Trying this out to the public highway is impossible for thereat of loosing my licene so the only option I can come to think of it a track day the problems however are:
1: My car is presently in a 1years free insurance with reanult and the insurance doesn't cover track days. SO how do I get insurance for the day and would having two sets of insurance on one car be odd/ illegal.
2: My car is a 1.5 65hp diesal so isn't exactly a world car performance car. So I don't want to try and race a Supra or other very quick car I just want to see how fast and well it handles for my own benefit and to for once see how much faster than the book it will achually go
3: I've never been to a race meeting or track in my life before and what exactly happens?
Any help please
Many thanks
Read more

Darren

Edd

Try Bookatrack.com
they organise days at various tracks and can offer insurance for your car at around 100 quid a day (insurance only), this obviously makes it expensive to see the speed but gives peace of mind that if you get in the way of a track day hack then you will still have a car.

M.M

Parts for these have been a bit of a pig for the past year or more. Even the local Halfords Superstore dealership had their parts counter removed. Now the only option to save a 60 mile round trip to the nearest official dealer parts counter in Leics is to phone the order to them and have the parts delivered to the local Halfords showroom on a Tues or Fri. An absolute nightmare for the Motor Enginer used to leaning over the dealer counter in town and getting the right parts there and then.

But it got a lot worse this week. Not only was I horrified at the cost of £175 for a timing belt plus tensioner and guide roller for a 1500cc Nexia but when trying to organise the parts delivery for this Fri find the sales area within Halfords had shut up shop without warning a day or so ago. Their notice on the closed door said something about Daewoo UK being in receivership.

Told the customer and sensibly he said sling it back together, I'll buy a new Honda Jazz this weekend. Wise move.

What price used Daewoos next week??

MM Read more

THe Growler

We have Mussos running round with Mercedes on them. Or could that just be rampant Asian piracy again?

We also have the Mitsubishi Pajero badged as the Hyundai Galloper. My local very Swiss Swiss Imbiss Stube bar-owner announces jovially "Mine burns zo moch benzin it must be called ze Golloper, no? ho-ho-ho!"

There is also age-ist remark about over 60's up there somewhere. If that's allowed then I want to be my sexist and racist self as well.


Change is mandatory, progress but a memory.



PDH

Can anyone suggest a reason why my 95 A6 2.0 misfires between 2-3Krpm, usually when under a light rather than hard load? Also, the idle speed oscillates intermittently. The main dealer has done a negative diagnostic test, and a good independant guy didn't find much either. I've tried fuel additive, at their suggestion, but to no effect. Read more

Richard Hall

My 1990 Coupe had the same problem. Eventually traced to faulty rotor arm in the distributor. Audi glue the rotor arm to the shaft (why?) and so none of the parts catalogues listed it, but after chiselling off the old arm, I took the remains to Halfords and found it was the same design as a Mk3 Escort.

Of course the 1995 A6 2.0 has a totally different engine, but might still be worth a look. Rotor arms, even for Audis, aren't very expensive.

Richard Hall
bangernomics.tripod.com

Roger K.

So the mobile phone companies have decided to use petrol forecourt price signs to hide their transmitters.

But are we not told not to use phones on forecourts for fear of explosions?
Surely base stations give out more radiation than a simple handset could.

Also, isn't it ironic that mobile phone-users expect a good signal anywhere they go, town or country, but nobody wants a transmitter near where they live, work, or go to school.
(I am one of the few people left that does not possess a mobile phone!) Read more

The Watcher

Sorry disagree. These mast cannot be described as 'high power able to cook an egg placed in close proximity.'

The risk of explosion from mobile phones in petrol stations is from the potential spark that may occur when a key is pressed ie when making or recieving a call.

In this sense the transmitters are passive. They do not cause a potential risk. Once again, the risk of starting an explosion in a petrol station is far more likely from the static spark from clothes when filling the car up.

r_welfare

Hi folks,

I've noticed recently that there's a lack of decent car ads on the "idiot lantern". So that got me thinking - what's the best-ever car ad you've seen on the telly?

Probably for me, it's got to have been the Nissan Almera ads from a few years back, aping The Sweeney and The Professionals. Spot-on impersonations and very entertaining.

Going back even further to the late 80s, the Montego ad where the car was put through it's paces in a works car park (handbrake turns etc - was the wheelman the renowned stunt driver Russ Swift?) was pretty good, of course the ASA would never allow such wanton displays of speed these days!

Any other suggestions? Read more

Dynamic Dave

Not so much a car ad,

But Chas & Dave's "He's got more rabbit than Sainsbury's" would be an apt advert for Bogush :o)

Motel

Can anybody help please, with a question about a phone charger
in A Rover 75 Conn Diesel Auto, I need to charge my phone from the cars Cigar lighter, but when i read the manual, it says not to use a charger, it may give a problem with the cars system any body help please Read more

John S

MOTEL

Odd. Several makers happily provide ciggy lighter sockets without the lighter, put a plastic cover on the top, and call them 'auxiliary power sockets'.

I can only assume Rover are being very cautious. One problem is that these sockets do vary, and some phone chargers fit better than others, so they may worried about potential short circuits. If it's live when the ignition is off, they may be worried obout the battery being flattened.

Personally I wouldn't worry, but you may consider if it's possible to fit a smaller fuse in the supply as a precaution since the phone charger will need far less current than the lighter (assuming you don't smoke).

Regards

John S