I got a cracked alloy welded rather than replaced - could this invalidate my insurance?

When my Mercedes-Benz C-Class was about three months old, during a safety check, the dealer discovered one of the rear wheels was cracked (pot hole I guess - but no loss of pressure). Rather than pay £600 for a new one, I paid a local specialist welding company to repair it. The car is now just over three years old and I was told recently this could invalidate my insurance in the event of an accident. Is this correct?

Asked on 14 May 2018 by LPG

Answered by Tim Kelly
If you had an accident as a result of the wheel failing, then yes, technically you could have your insurance invalidated because you were aware of it. Welding alloys is a big no, I definitely would never have it done. If it is fractured, bin it. Imagine if your wheel failed and, as a result, it killed somebody for the sake of £600. Has the repaired alloy been x-rayed or dye tested?
Aluminum needs to be stuck in an oven to get extremely hot before being welded, especially if it cast/forged. Few specialists have the facilities to do this.
Similar questions
I damaged two of my 2015 Fiat 500 alloy wheels on a kerb and each has a small chip on the rim. Refurbishing two wheels costs £160 - £220 and I will not be sure that they are safe. Fiat wheels are £700...
I have just had two new tyres fitted by my local tyre fitters. During the fitting of the new tyres to the wheels, they scored each of the spokes on both alloys in a constant radius. They apologised and...
I have just purchased a new Skoda Karoq Scout with 19-inch wheels as standard. In the past three days I have managed heartbreakingly to kerb two of the wheels. In all my years of driving I cannot remember...
Related models
Excellent refinement and very composed ride quality. Quiet diesel engine. Superb cabin quality. Spacious for rear seat passengers. Capable off-road if need be. Revamped with Mild Hybrid in 2019.

Ask Honest John

Value my car