November 2001

Chad R

My Xantia Estate 1.9TD seems to be suffering from an engine boom (noise) at over 2500rpm, certainly more noticeable and gets louder through higher revs. It?s just the same engine noise as usual, but a bit louder.
(Doesn?t sound like a leaky exhaust or similar, though it may be from the manifold??)
The power seems to be very slightly down too, but that may be my down to my imagination.

Any ideas what may be causing this?

Chad.R

PS. The car has done 127K miles, always serviced every 6K, cambelt replaced at 125K and clutch replaced at 108K etc. etc. Read more

John Slaughter

Richard

Surely Cooler exhaust gas = lower exhaust temps = more condensation= more corrosion?

Must be some other effect.

Regards

JS

Gary

Has antone come across the site www.bmwparts.uk.com they state that they obtain their parts direct from Germany at upto 70% off of UK prices. Read more

richard turpin

"German and Sweedish" sell BMW parts at good value eg; £14 for a 323 clutch slave cylinder.

Matt

The Radio Display(which is also the Information display and Climate Control Display have started to read very strangely. There are parts of the display missing as if bulbs have gone. Anybody come accros this before? Is it likely to cost a fortune at Mr saab? Read more

John Slaughter

I imagine because of the parentage, there are similarities with the unit used in Vectras.

I've seen a few of those failed - various sections of the display missing, not always consistently. Started when my car was under 2 years old.

Fix on mine was new unit, but as it was a company car I didn't see the bill. The replacement was fine after 2+ years when sold.

Regards

JS

JohnM

FYI: Latest set of crash tests have been published on following cars:
BMW 3 Series, Citroen C5, Mondeo, Hyundi Elantra, 406, Octavia, Volvo S60,
Honda Stream, Alfa 147, Peugeot 307, Rover 25.

Details of these, and previous tests are on www.euroncap.com.
They make interesting (and sobering) reading...

(Look at the test results in detail, you'll see the star ratings seem to cover a wide range of performance.) Read more

Tomo

These things are all of course related to secondary safety.

Primary safety lies in the dynamic qualities of the vehicle which enable one to keep or get out of trouble. Unfortunately the best vehicles in this respect are also the most satisfying and desirable, and are loaded with various excess costs which are really amenity charges.

Oliver Goldsmith

I have a 2.5 year old Golf from new. 20,000 miles on the clock.
Volkswagen informed me that the brake pads were 80% worn and should be replaced. Okay. BUT they also told me that all 4 discs were badly lipped and must also be replaced. I found this absurd and told them so. I have never had to replace discs before on any car. I would have accepted their advice if the brake pads had worn down completely, but they were only 80% worn. Total cost with labour was over £600
Since I needed the car, I told them to go ahead but to keep me the pads and discs as I would take the matter up with Volkswagen H.O. Correspondence has been going back and forth for several months and they deny any responsibility, as its doewn to fair wear and tear. By the way, they have never examined the discs, only accepted the word of the Garage.
Their last letter told me to seek advice from another Volkswagen dealer, as they would not entertain my request to have their own technicians examine the discs themselves. I don't intend to let them get away with this so easily.
Has anyone had a similar problem wit the discs?
My worry is that on the basis of what they have told me, its looks like new discs every 20,000 miles and I find their pricing a little too hot for comfort! Read more

Julian Lindley

Excellent and accurate advice Kieth.

The disc thickness and wear tolerance will be in a Haynes manual. A vernier gauge or a micrometer are easy to purchase and relatively inexpensive when compared to the effort required to seek alternative routes.

Disc and brake replacement is very cheap on my home maintained Cavalier and Astra SRI. I do however keep a log book which is really helpful in planning preventative maintenance and oil changes.

Julian

Ian

Any recommendations on the pros and cons of fitting 205 16" alloys to a Saab 93 convertible (195 15" steel as standard). Can I use the same wheel bolts? Are stick on balancing weights better than the clip on types or do they come off in time, I've seen new Audis with vinyl coated weights on alloys but most tyre places seem to apply the standard weights with all the finesse of a blacksmith!! Are these vinyl coated weights available elsewhere?

Thanks, Ian Read more

Mike H

Saab sell a whole range of 16" whhels for a 9-3, as long as the aspect ratio is correct (e.g. you might need 205/55x16 to replace a 196/96x15) you will be OK.

Check also whether these are genuine Saab alloys, then if they are, get hold of the Saab accessory brochure because it tells you which wheels fit which Saab - not all Saab 16" wheels will fit both 9-3 and 9-5, some are specific to each model although 16" can be fitted to both (if you follow me).

Andrew Petterson

A friend of mine bought a 97R 306 1.4 LX at an auction about 6 weeks ago. The car was an ex-fleet, had done 57,000 miles had a full dealer service history, seemed to have been run by a lady owner. Everything checked out, bodywork perfect, tyres correct etc etc. It ran very sweetly when I helped check it out at the auction. We paid 3,600 for it. It was due for a service, so we took it in to a local independent garage. About 2 weeks after the service, the car started to develop a rumbling/knocking noise whilst pulling off. After much poking around, he bit the bullet and booked it in to the local Peugeot franchise for investigation. After the master tech and workshop foreman had looked at it, they diagnosed probable play in the crankshaft. My question is, what should I do about it. Would an independent specialist rebuild the engine rather than pay £1700 for a new engine, or being handy with the spanners myself, and having a Haynes manual to hand should I have a go myself? Will I need a complete new crank or do you think that replacing the bearing shells will be enough?
Also, do I have any recompense against Peugeot?

Sorry for the long question

Many thanks

Andy Read more

Andrew Petterson

We took the car into a halfords/aa garage. (Are these people any good?) and the guy there said he reckoned the noise is coming from the top end, so this weekend i'm going to open up the rocker cover and check for play in the camshaft. Also, he too like Diesel, reckoned that there might be an oil pressure problem. One point, the oil filter is a Bosch are these any good, also, the garage put Duckhams QRX in apparently, I don't think that stuff is any good, is it worth doing another oil change with a Purflux oil filter and Magnatec/Mobil 1?

Cheers

Andy

alvin booth

Our esteemed Chancellor has give us warnings of increased taxation.
The golden goose of motoring will no doubt be in line for plucking.
What new methods will he use.
Doubt he can go for fuel again as the truckers will react.
The environment is always a favourite so which part of it will his spin doctors be looking at to make us think he is doing us all a favour.
Alvin Read more

Sue

THe Growler....and so the hand wrote:
> INcidentally shootouts are not uncommon in the loca;s'
> karaokes, someone did some research and found "MY Way" sung
> badly was the most common reason.

Sounds like an eminently reasonable response to me!

Alan Wainwright

In Saturday's Telegraph, HJ recommended the use of 'high-detergent' petrol to help cure starting problems on a Vauxhall Nova. My wife's '95 1.1 litre Fiesta suffers similar problems described for the Nova. What is 'high-detergent' petrol, and how do I recognise the appropriate brands? Any thoughts very welcome. Read more

RogerL

Is the Shell detergent the same one that wrecked all the police Senators when it was introduced in the '80s.

All petrol is the same until the additives are added. In most cases, petrol travels along underground pipelines to the distribution centres from one single refinery. It is then loaded into tankers with a little additive, so basically all petrol is the same, in any one area.

Oldsinjun

For info. to anyone who has a Ford Explorer with Firestone tyres, Ford have just changed all my Firestones for Goodyear Wranglers....for FREE.

It still depreciates like a stone but good value. Read more

THe Growler

Wranglers are now the factory fit on all Ford SUV's ex Detroit according to the dealer I got my Lariat from