Should you admit liability after an accident?

I often read in your questions that the third party admitted liability. I always understood that one must NOT do that as it will reduce the negotiating stance of the insurance company. Otherwise, fault can only be apportioned in the courts. Can one admit liability these days as it was a no-no when I started to drive over 40 years ago?

Asked on 19 February 2018 by Guy

Answered by Tim Kelly
The insurer will advise that you should not admit liability as it may prejudice their stance. Ultimately, the claim, and any claim made against you is your claim. If an incident was your fault, then you are not going to prejudice any claim against you by admitting to it. You have paid the insurer to indemnify you against any loss you may have incurred as a result of your negligence. Ultimately, fault can only be apportioned by the courts, but the court would frown upon someone or insurer who forced a case to go to court when it was clear from the onset they were liable. I would still advise everyone not to admit anything at the scene though, as it may provide an opportunity for your insurer to try and avoid the claim for some reason, and that is never wise.
Similar questions
A friend asked if someone with whom he had done a house and car swap, could drop off his car at my house. When the car arrived he had his wife and two teenage children with him. They needed to go to the...
If I am driving on two-lane, one-way road and am in the left lane, indicating to move over into a right-hand junction, then start to move into the right-hand junction and someone hits me at the rear end...
My parked car was crashed into by a drink driver at night, I was at home sleeping. The police arrested him for drink driving and criminal damage and arranged the recovery. My insurance (Tesco) is third...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car