I do 12,000 miles per year with occasional long trips - should I get a petrol or diesel car?

I'm considering a nearly new, top spec Nissan Qashqai and I'm unsure whether to opt for a petrol or diesel model. The car will be mostly used for commuting. My journey is 20 miles from home to office, half to two-thirds of the journey is 60-70mph roads. The rest is motorway stop-start congestion and typical rush hour town traffic. The car will also be used occasionally for long journeys to visit family (150+ miles). My annual mileage is unlikely to be more than 12,000 per year and I intend to keep the car for the long haul. On the diesel model, is the DPF technology similar to other manufacturers and potentially a cause for concern later in the car's life? Are there any alternatives to the Qashqai (in a similar price range) I should consider?

Asked on 30 October 2017 by

Answered by Honest John
For 12,000 miles a year you can't justify diesel and the problems it is likely to bring. Better the 1.2 DIG-T or, for more performance, the 163PS 1.6 DIG-T. The Renault Kadjar is actually better than the Qashqai. Much tougher, especially with 4WD. But no 1.6 turbo petrol option yet. Make sure you order the car on 17-inch wheels with 215/60 R17 tyres. Don't go for the 19-inch bling wheels with 45 profile tyres or you'll regret it.
Similar questions
I want to trade in my 2011 diesel Nissan X-Trail 2.2 for a slightly smaller 4WD. I commute 50 miles a day, but need a 4WD for rough farm tracks. I have a budget of about £20,000 - £25,000 after trading...
I would like to buy a second-hand (3 year old) Nissan Qashqai 1.5 diesel as it has the best review. I do about 9000 miles per year but I'm concerned with the press surrounding diesels and emissions, as...
We own and run a 2013 Kia Sportage II 1.7, but because of changing lifestyles it rarely gets to stretch its legs. We love the high driving position and our travel is now a 24 mile daily round trip for...
Related models
Comfortable to drive with a robust interior, good engines, popularity means lots of choice on the used market.
Spacious and practical family SUV, low running costs, mid-range models are well-equipped.


Value my car