Should the supplying dealer pay for a new tyre after unusual wear was found on my BMW 3 Series?

I bought a 58-plate BMW 3 Series convertible in December 2010. I took it into a BMW dealer for an oil and brake service, where they told me there was wear on the offside tyre on the inside edge and it needed replacing. Ive only done 5000 miles since picking up the car. The BMW technician at Chester told me this was 'unusual' wear, normally associated with running with a flat tyre. I have never run with a flat tyre nor had a puncture in this tyre. I believe this wear was there when I picked the car up and suspect the car was not checked properly. No one would ever have noticed this unless the car was on ramps. The dealer does not want to know as nine months have elapsed. Have I any grounds here to get them to pay for the tyre and alignment check?

Asked on 1 September 2010 by PeteBod

Answered by Honest John
You might have damaged it on a kerb or speed hump or pothole. It's too difficult to prove that the damage was present when you bought the car.
Similar questions
I have a 3-year-old Honda Jazz 1.4ES. There's never been a problem with the car, except for excessive tyre wear on the front inner edge of the driver's side. I've been back to the Honda garage and they...
My new 2004 Mondeo Estate (2Ltr Petrol) was supplied fitted with Continental Premium Contact 205/55/16 tyres. These lasted on the front for an acceptable 21000 miles with the rears following on a few K...
Further to the recent letter from HP in Reading, I have had similar experience with two Polos in the last few years. Both were new company cars that prematurely munched a set of front tyres in less than...
Related models
Superb to drive. Great handling and steering. Upmarket image. Economical diesel engines culminating in amazingly efficient 320d Efficient Dynamics at 109g/km of CO2.

Ask Honest John

Value my car