Claiming on extended warranty - should I have to pay anything?

I had reason recently to claim against a third party warranty. My car is a SAAB 9-3 XWD 2010. I took my car into my local garage for assessment. They diagnosed problem as a failing offside front wheel bearing.

The warranty company approved the claim. However they advised the garage where to buy the bearing and the cost. Furthermore the specified time for the job was quoted as 0.7hour. I was advised that this information is taken from Autodata.

The garage completed the job, however I was advised that the time taken was 2.5 hours. I therefore had to pay the difference i.e. 1.8 hours. There should not have been any unforeseen problems removing the bearing as the same garage replaced all my brake discs a month ago.

I am not familiar with the autodata guidance information but was wondering how realistic is this data given the fact that my local garage has charged almost 4 times the allocated time to complete the job?

Asked on 24 May 2016 by Frankie 59

Answered by Honest John
If that is what is specified in your warranty contract then that is what applied. Obviously a local garage unfamiliar with the job on a particular car and lacking the correct equipment would take longer than the specified times. Bit difficult with a SAAB anyway because there are no official franchises left even though some ex SAAB franchises simply carried on as independents.
Similar questions
I have a four year old Mercedes-Benz SLK with 19,700 miles on the clock. I've owned it for a year and it has been covered by a warranty, which has now just expired. So far, it has had a new RPM sensor,...
Hi, I bought a Mini Cooper S 2009 plate just over 3 months ago (1/10/15) and a few days ago the engine cut out - the rac towed me to the nearest mini dealer and they think the timing chain/belt has snapped...
We bought our August 2011 Passat in Feb 2013, second hand from available car. It was still under warranty and we took out an extra 2 year extended warranty. Within months the boot would not shut and...
Related models
More of the same. Modernised with sharper looks. Quick 2.8 twin-turbo. Strong diesels. Spare parts still readily available.

Ask Honest John

Value my car