Old car for old

Recently I wrote off my beloved car, which I had purchased new, three years ago from a Mazda dealer. The insurer, Swiftcover, wants to supply me with another vehicle the same as my old one, but I would rather go out and buy it from my dealer as then if I have any problems I can go back to the dealer who has always been brilliant with me. What are my legal rights when it comes to write off replacement vehicles?

Asked on 27 March 2010 by S.B., via e-mail

Answered by Honest John
I'm pleasantly surprised and very interested that your insurer is seeking to supply you with a like-for-like car rather than just the money. I've never heard of that before. Of course, an insurer replacing a car through the trade (possibly using a trade buyer at auction) can get a better deal than you would get through a dealer. The insurer might offer money instead, but that would not buy as much car from a dealer as the insurer could supply via the trade.
Similar questions
My cherished 2005 Porsche Boxster 987S was involved in an accident last week and was sadly declared a write-off by the insurance company. I bought it from a dealer (for peace of mind) but the insurer's...
A garage crashed my car which is now written off. The driver was negligent and has been charged. Their insurers are now offering market value for the car I have paid for for last 3 years with still another...
At 70 mph in lane 2 the bonnet of my Saab 9-3 Sportwagon (1.8 Biopower, 64000 miles, excellent condition) flew open, causing damage to the bonnet, both wings and roof. Estimate for repair is £2500 exc...

Value my car