Can I claim for the loss in value of my car following an accident that wasn't my fault?

I have a Mercedes-Benz GLC first registered in March 2017. A third party car recently rear-ended me. He had insurance and accepted liability. His insurance has repaired the car, but a colleague has mentioned that as the car will now be registered as having had an accident which will reduce its value and I can claim for the loss of value, is this correct?

Asked on 28 August 2019 by Derrick Haynes

Answered by Tim Kelly
Your colleague is misadvising you. The car is not recorded/registered as being involved in an accident, as such that on its own will not decrease its value. What your colleague may be talking about is Diminution in Loss". This basically means that if you have been involved in an accident that was not your fault, then it could be argued your vehicle has been “reduced” in value due to being damaged and now repaired (even when repaired to a perfectly satisfactory standard).

The case law around it is based on a case called “Payton-v-Brooks” 1974 where it was argued that, if you have two vehicles at a point of sale, that the one that had the connotation of being involved in an accident, would be worth less than one that had.

This set legal precedent, meaning that it is a legal header of a claim that you can claim for. It is a complicated arena. You are always entitled to claim for Diminution in Loss, however, the level of diminution achieved may not make it worthwhile claiming or a court may frown upon a low-value claim being submitted. The level of diminution is related to the type of vehicle, extent of damage and other variables.
Similar questions
At a recent family reunion, my friend's partner backed into my car in torrential rain - before I'd even moved - causing serious damage to my car. He shot off at great speed, driving in a highly dangerous...
If someone damages my car while it's in a car park (public/private) or on the public road and their insurance pays for the damage, do I need to declare this accident on my insurance renewal?
While parked in a supermarket car park, the rear of my car was hit by a lady driving into to the space to my right. The driver of the vehicle parked in the bay to her right witnessed the accident and I...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car