Should I get a Ford Fiesta 1.0 Ecoboost or 1.6 petrol Powershift?

I'm considering a new/used Ford Fiesta Powershift but my local independent garage (very experienced and trustworthy) has warned me off the 1.0 Ecoboost engine as he has seen a number of failures. He says it's Turbo charging and high output from a tiny engine makes it fragile and unreliable. My own research has revealed lots of problems with the Ecoboost engine. Should I buy the 1.6 petrol Powershift instead? Does it drive differently from the Ecoboost? I'm not bothered about mpg because of low mileage. Long-term reliability is much more important.

Asked on 21 February 2017 by Johnfrog

Answered by Honest John
There's a weak plastic/nylon union in the return coolant pipe from the turbo to the expansion tank (called the 'degas' pipe) of the 1.0 EcoBoost. If that is properly replaced, no problem. But there's a problem with the Poweshift. The twin dry clutch packs fail regularly. Get a small Hyundai or a Kia or a Mazda 2 with a 4-speed torque converter auto.
Similar questions
Our 6 year old Jaguar XF Portfolio, which we like, is due for a change. Annual mileage is around 8000 - mostly short journeys, but 4/5 times a year 700 mile return trips. Main requirement is comfort on...
I currently own a 2015 Renault Kadjar 1.5 diesel. We bought the car due to its ability to carry large loads, comfort on long journeys and fuel economy. It's been brilliant. I'm now considering changing...
It's time to change my Toyota Corolla 1.6 VVTi which has basically given 128,000 trouble free miles. I intend to gift this car and then buy a petrol replacement outright. Not so sure about a Toyota Auris...
Related models
Impressive small hatch that offers a fine blend of comfort and handling. Good economy. Well equipped as standard. The best looking and altogether nicest small car in the class.
Most versions good to drive, especially ST-Line but significantly more refined. Comfortable and practical. Comes with active safety technology as standard.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car