Which of our cars should we sell and what do we replace them with?

We have a 2013 Honda CR-V EX (31,000 miles), a 2012 MINI Cooper (25,000 miles) and a 2014 MINI Roadster JCW (7500 miles). All in good condition. We want to reduce the cars from 3 to 2 and still need to transport 2 dogs. Wife needs a car but not huge and husband requires something a bit sporty. So far I'm looking to buy either a Honda HR-V and keep the Roadster or a Mini Clubman either "S" or "JCW" and keep the Cooper. Which two of our cars would you lose?

Asked on 27 January 2017 by Driver55

Answered by Honest John
I'd be inclined to keep the MINI Roadster JCW because that's the only one likely to acquire classic status. The Honda HR-V 1.6 i-DTEC on Michelin Cross Climate tyres is excellent and economical with an astonishing amount of room inside for the footprint (like a Jazz). So that's my answer.
Similar questions
I'm looking at the Kia seven year warranty, is it any good? I'm looking at the Kia Sportage. Do you have any reviews on the new version? How economical are they in practice?
I'm hoping for advice on the best new economical and practical vehicle to buy with a long warranty. Or perhaps advice on the best secondhand model for my needs as an older female drive. My ideal car/van...
We're looking for a petrol automatic SUV/crossover with good mpg and fully spec'd for short daily use, with occasional long journeys. We are looking at the Volkswagen Touareg, Hyundai Tucson and Honda...
Related models
Great performance from Cooper S, much smoother and more sophisticated than first generation, capable of travelling distances in comfort.
1.6 i-DTEC is punchy and efficient, massive boot and a spacious cabin for five adults, superb build quality edges the CR-V into premium territory.
Looks more sporty and purposeful than the MINI Convertible. Enjoyable to drive. Offers plenty of customisation
Highly practical and versatile thanks to 'magic' seats. Strong i-DTEC diesel.
Now a proper estate with two rear doors, more upmarket interior than standard MINI hatch, good sized boot has plenty of room for a pushchair.


Value my car