Which convertible to replace our Hyundai i30?

I drive a Vauxhall Insignia Elite hatchback with leather upholstery, satnav and all the bells and whistles. Terrific car, I'm delighted with it. Currently, my wife drives a Hyundai i30 hatchback, which is three years old. We are thinking of selling it and buying a convertible, as, after many years of financial struggle, we are now able to indulge ourselves to a modest degree. Given the size of our double garage we cannot fit anything much wider than the Hyundai, the limit being by a few inches. We are thinking of getting something less than one year old with less than 7500 miles on the clock, possibly an ex-demonstration model. But what make and model? We looked at a 1.4-litre and 2.0-litre Volkswagen Golf which, with the diesel engine, apparently delivers amazing fuel efficiency. But there must be other makes and models. Have you any recommendations including, if you plumped for a Golf, which model you prefer?

Asked on 6 April 2013 by RT, London SW1

Answered by Honest John
Audi A3 and BMW 1 Series convertibles are small and sweet. Best not diesel unless you intend driving 20,000 miles a year in it. The 1.4TSI 122 in the Golf and A3 is entirely adequate. And try to stick to 16-inch wheels in order to enjoy at least some ride comfort.
Similar questions
I am looking to buy a late Pluriel. Could you tell me which is the best engine and is the diesel a modern one with a DPF or is at an older style?
My wife has a much-loved MX5, complete with detachable hardtop. However, it is beginning to look as if we might need to replace it, as we are both in our 70's, I am now having difficulty getting out of...
Is there another small convertible to rival my ageing Fiat 500C? I want something that is just as compact, has a back seat to take a dog or small people and, unlike the MINI convertible, looks nice!...
Related models
Great range of diesel and petrol engines. High-tech yet intuitive nav and media system. Slick ride and handling.
Comfortable and high quality premium hatchback. Low emissions diesel engines including economical 1.6 TDI. Very refined at speed yet handles well in corners.
Seventh generation Golf sets perceived quality benchmark for class. More spacious than before. Better to drive. Refined and comfortable. Multiple award winner.

Ask Honest John

Value my car