Do you have a minute to answer an electric vehicle survey? Start the survey | No thanks

Which diesel SUV for rural use?

We currently drive a Mercedes-Benz SLK and a Fiesta but with both of these cars I am now experiencing back/leg pain after driving for an hour or so. Earlier in year we holidayed in the USA where we drove long distances in a Jeep 4x4, which caused me no discomfort at all. In view of this we are considering buying an SUV. Even though we live in a very rural area we don't plan to go off-road, and the only possible justification for having four wheel drive would be for snow covered lanes, for typically two or three weeks each year. We do around 17,000 miles a year in the Fiesta and 7000 in the SLK and we would be looking to buy a diesel of 12 to 18 months old. Although I really like the performance and economy of the X3 the initial outlay looks a bit steep. Does the X3 justify its price tag, and can you suggest any other alternative SUVs, about the size of the X3 with reasonable performance that we should consider?

Asked on 19 January 2013 by RD, Peasenahall

Answered by Honest John
The BMW X3 2.0d 4WD (X-drive) is the best. Other contenders include the Mazda CX-5, Honda CR-V (tested here:, the forthcoming new Toyota RAV4 (, forthcoming new Ford Kuga ( and VAG models such as the Skoda Yeti, Audi Q3 and Volkswagen Tiguan.

Remember that the deeper the profile of the tyres the more comfortable the ride will be. Do not go below 55 and preferably not below 60 profile tyres on an SUV.
Similar questions
I am looking to replace a 2009 Volkswagen Tiguan 2.0TDI 4-Motion, which has a towbar and has been a delight to drive. The whole of our grown-up family enjoys its roominess and adaptability. Its only drawback...
Could you please tell me which SUV has the best legroom and roof height for OAP's with knee problems? Looking at a Honda CR-V, its swept-back roof line makes that one unlikely; so perhaps a Skoda or Subaru?
My wife and I are both retired and live near Oxford. Once a week we drive to Suffolk, a round trip of some 300 miles, which contributes to a joint annual mileage of around 30,000 miles. We have two 60...
Related models
Stylish. compact SUV in a similar fashion to the Range Rover Evoque. Impressive fuel economy and low CO2. Two and four-wheel drive available.
Unique styling. Solid build. Excellent petrol engines including frugal yet peppy 1.2 TSI. Good space in the back. Frugal 1.6 TDI Greenline can return 60mpg+.
Decent SUV with diesel automatic option. Comfortable seats. Escape version capable off-road. Optional Park Assist works well. Much better from September 2011 facelift.
Handling is impressive for an SUV, large boot capacity and lots of rear-seat space, top engine choices deliver serious performance.
Economical and efficient. Comfortable ride. Well equipped as standard. Practical and spacious yet compact.
1.6 i-DTEC is punchy and efficient, massive boot and a spacious cabin for five adults, superb build quality edges the CR-V into premium territory.
Class-leading handling, practical and spacious interior, plenty of examples to choose from.
Practical with a good boot and plenty of rear leg room. 2.5 hybrid with 2WD or 4WD available. Five year warranty. Proving very reliable.

Value my car