Is a front-wheel-drive car on winter tyres better than a 4WD car on summer tyres?

You write that a FWD car on winter tyres is better than a 4WD car on summer tyres. Clearly you have little experience of driving in the snow and ice and it’s flat where you live. In Devon there are lanes that never get cleared or gritted by local authorities.

Asked on 2 November 2012 by TP, Barnsaple

Answered by Honest John
I began driving in Northumberland, where winters used to last from October to April and snow from November to March. I drove all sorts of cars in deep snow, including a 1949 Rover P3. Basically I am repeating extremely well known advice from Germany, Austria and Italy. Worst: RWD on summers. Next worst: FWD on summers. Next worst: AWD on summers (though, of course, depends on level of sophistication of the AWD system). Better: RWD on full winters. Better still: FWD on full winters. Best of the lot: AWD on full winters. Even better: AWD with studded winters or with chains.

Not only that, at less than 8 degrees centigrade, any car on cold weather tyres stops in about half the distance of one on summer tyres, whether 4WD or not.
Similar questions
I am looking to spend up to £15,000 on a secondhand car for my wife, who only will do 4000 miles per year so I'm looking at one or two year-old car. I would like either front wheel drive or 4X4, as we're...
I was very interested in your answer to MA of Stroud regarding the merits of a winter tyre-shod Porsche Carrera S rear wheel drive against the 4WD version without winter tyres. As I currently drive a Skoda...
I thought you might like to hear that we bought the S-Max you suggested to replace a Land Rover Discovery 3 and can confirm your advice that the winter tyres are definitely much better than 4-wheel-drive...

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer