Ask a Question

Turbo failure: worth fixing or get a different car

I bought a Grand Megane scenic 54 plate last tuesday and when I took it to work the day after the turbo charger failed causing a huge cloud of black smoke smoke and significant lost of power. I could not stop immediately due to the road I was on and probably drove for 1 mile.

The dealer is willing to replace the turbo and is reassuring me the car will be fixed to high standards. The engine has got 80k miles (genuine). The car has been regularly serviced by a renault dealer. It had a few majors (instrument panel, oil pump/switch, engine mounting) sorted by Renault dealer.

My dilemma is will the engine survive such a blow? Will I have the same problem in the near future? Should I get the vehicle checked privately after the job has been done or should I try to get the money back?

Asked on by

Never replace a turbo without replacing all the oil feed pipework as well. Turbos usually fail because the oil in the bearings cokes up from the engine having been switched off when the turbo was too hot. The oil in the feed pipes to the turbo can also coke up, starving the turbo (and the replacement turbo) of oil leading to another disaster within 1,000 miles.
Similar questions
My Dad has been having horrendous trouble with his Volvo XC60. He purchased it from new in June 2011. Since then it has spent many, many weeks back at Volvo. The computer system fails in part - taking...
During a service in July 2008, the main dealer noticed oil in the expansion tank and the oil cooler had to be replaced and engine flushed (£800 of which I contributed 33%) They did'nt do the job correctly...
My son bought a one-year old Volkswagen Scirocco a few days ago, and when we got it home, we found the centres of the front tyres were badly worn down to the wear indicators. The garage claims that cars...
Related models
Comfortable for seven. Great chain-cam 1.4 TCe 130 engine. Brilliant new chain-cam 1.6 dCi 130 diesel engine from mid 2011.

Ask Honest John

Value my car