A buyer bought, modified and then broke a car I sold him. Can he legally claim money from me?

I live in Scotland and sold a car privately to someone from England, the new owner later sent me a text to say it was running fine after he had done a few miles. He then put different wheels on and other modification, as well as changing the number plate. He finally took it to a rolling road where the engine was 'tweeked' to give more horsepower. The car subsequently blew up. He is now trying to claim against me for a new engine. What are my rights?

Asked on 12 January 2021 by Peter J L

Answered by Georgia Petrie
Private sales are less protected by the 2015 Consumer Rights so, to keep things as short as possible, the car legally only needs to be as you described it. It should be true to the advert and what you told the person who bought it from you. He won’t be entitled to anything just because the car is faulty or because the seller (you) failed to mention something in the advert. However, the law also takes fair wear and tear into account. So, for example, if the car had been clocked with a fake milage, the buyer would be entitled to a refund because you'd lied. However, if he knowingly bought a vehicle with 150,000 miles on it and then it broke down, he won't be entitled to anything. If the car isn't as you described it (I personally don't know what you said in the advert), then the buyer can ask for the difference in value between what you paid and what the car is really worth or a refund. My understanding is also that because the buyer has modified the vehicle (especially the engine), they aren't entitled to a refund, though.

Unfortunately, you haven't really given us enough details to help more - but these generals should help you make your own mind up as to whether he has any basis to claim money back from you. Based on what you've told us, I don't think he has rights against you. But my advice would be to seek free legal help from Citizens Advice.
Similar questions
What's the legal position over a car advertised as a private sale, but which appears to be from a trader? There's a car advertised on the local Gumtree as a private sale, but on closer inspection the same...
As a private seller I sold our 13 year old Land Rover to a dealer after a telephone call giving a description of the vehicle condition. A price was agreed. A driver came to pick it up in exchange for...
I privately sold a car 3-4 weeks ago. Now they've come back with a huge bill saying the clutch has gone even though it was serviced three weeks before. It was sold as all okay with no advisories. Who has...
 

Ask Honest John Right column

Value my car