What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks

Morning after pull

The local Police have been conducting random breath tests on people driving to work in the early morning. Whilst I do not condone drink driving I cannot find any evidence to suggest that the Police have a legal right to request a breath test under these circumstances. In my view the only occasions that a breath test can be requested on a road or public place is under Section 8 of The Road Traffic Act 1972. In this Act it specifies three occasions when a test can be requested: a) when the driver is suspected of having alcohol in his body; b) when the driver is suspected of having committed a moving traffic offence; or c) if an accident occurs and that person is suspected of being the driver at the time. Since neither b nor c applies in random tests then this only leaves a) suspected of having alcohol in the drivers body. How can a Police Officer when seeing a vehicle being driven towards him in a perfectly respectful manner at 8.30am in the morning suspect the driver of having alcohol in his body? I accept that once the vehicle has stopped and the Officer smells alcohol or has some other reason for forming the opinion that the driver is unfit to drive through drink or drugs that the Officer then has power of arrest under Section 5 of The Road Traffic Act 1972. There is however no provision under this section to request a specimen of breath for a breath test at the roadside. I would be pleased to receive your observations and comments on the above.

Asked on 14 February 2009 by

Answered by Honest John
Catching morning after drinkers. Depends on body metabolisms. I think this is nasty and unfair policing, the results of which can put drivers out of work. But the victim of a morning drunk would not. And since a normal (male) body should metabolise 8 - 12 units of alcohol between 8.30pm and 8.30am, drivers caught the morning after must have had a dangerously excessive amount to drink.
Similar questions
A very dear friend of mine has to appear in court later this month charged with failing to provide a specimen of breath. If found guilty, she will receive a driving ban. In this event, I have offered to...
A delivery driver who works next door to me, told of an incident about two weeks ago. He was driving his car to work in South London when he was stopped at a Police ANPR checkpoint and asked for his driving...
I forward this email to you in total frustration at the way that the traffic police and their partners manage their dealings with the tax paying public. I have only ever had four speeding endorsements...