What has happened to make insurance premiums go up so much in the last 12 months?

Last July I insured my car for £240. This year, with no changes to my circumstances (other than the value of the car having reduced) the renewal quote was £380. I’m fully aware of how insurers tend to treat existing customers, so as always I researched comparison sites, but was amazed that the cheapest quote I could get was £300, for a that policy excluded driving abroad. I ended up paying £331 through Debenhams Insurance to get the cover I needed. What is happening in the world of car insurance to justify this?

Asked on 16 July 2018 by Steve Tremlett

Answered by Tim Kelly
There was an increase in premium tax last year, that and an amendment to the Ogden rate, which mean insurers had to Increase their reserves, Insurers have strongly petitioned the Government over whiplash claims in an attempt to deny lawful claimants, while advising the potential savings (initially quoted by Aviva insurance to George Osbourne the then current Chancellor savings of £95 per policy) this then changed, to £75,then £45, now the massive saving of £25 per policy. All the while trying to push reforms through via the criminal justice bill which would potentially save them billions in personal injury claims by increasing the PI claims limit to £5000 (this means you will only be able to use a solicitor for claims over this amount).

This means you would have to represent yourself in court and would ultimately end up receiving £600 for a whiplash injury compared to £1600-2000. This leads to your question, as insurers should be passing these savings on to honest members of the public. And yet they never have, probably never will. Despite the fact they had one of the best underwriting years ever making more profit than they have done. What is the justification for premiums to increase? There isn't one.
Similar questions
We have insurance on previous car where I was a primary driver/policy holder and my partner was a named driver. She had a minor accident in Sep 2017 for which we are in dispute and just yesterday the claims...
I’ve just passed my practical test and every insurance quote I’ve had is over £1000. Do you know of any insurance companies that maybe cheaper?
I’m buying a nearly new BMW X3 20d Sport which comes with 20-inch wheels. I have asked the dealer, who agreed, to swap these for 18-inch wheels. Asking for an insurance quote I was told that this change...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car