Which products have made it into the Honest John Kit gift guides for Christmas 2019? You'll be surprised... | No thanks

Our Cars: Hyundai Kona 1.6 T-GDi 4WD DCT Premium GT

21 May 2019: Should I buy a petrol or diesel crossover?

The Details

Current mileage 5597
Claimed economy 40.4mpg
Actual economy 33mpg

British buyers love 4x4s, SUVs and crossovers. Models like our Hyundai Kona have been convincing buyers - who in previous years would have been tempted towards hatchbacks, estates and MPVs - to part with their money for a larger vehicle.

And it's no wonder these larger cars are so popular. They offer more space, practicality and safety tech than many of their smaller rivals. But one question we're regularly asked from those looking to upgrade to a bigger car is... should you get a petrol or diesel?

Generally, we advise those who live in urban areas or cover low miles to buy a petrol. Those with higher annual mileages including plenty of motorway driving should opt for a diesel.

So, who exactly is our Hyundai Kona 1.6-litre petrol 4x4 aimed at? The 4x4 capability of the Kona is ideal for those who live in the countryside or want to cover challenging terrain, while the petrol engine is better for those who don't do many miles. If you buy a diesel for predominantly short journeys, you risk the diesel particulate filter (DPF) blocking up - resulting in an expensive bill.

Kona Long Shot

Having moved to a city recently, most of my journeys are around 15 miles or less - with very few of these being done on a motorway for more than a few miles.

Sounds ideal, although fuel economy has taken a hit compared with a diesel. Our Kona's only managing about 33mpg - despite an official economy figure of more than 40mpg. That's quite thirsty for a small crossover.

Our fuel bills aren't as costly as a DPF replacement, but if you cover more than around 12,000 miles a year and need 4x4, we'd recommend a diesel.

So, is a petrol 4x4 really only an option if you mainly travel short distances? In our opinion, yes. But we'd probably avoid the all-wheel-drive system unless you really needed it...

« Earlier: In the case of the Kona, the electric model comes out on top    

21 May 2019: Should I buy a petrol or diesel crossover?
When it comes to crossovers and SUVs, Georgia covers whether it's best to go for petrol or diesel.
The Kona EV is better than Georgia's petrol model. But does that mean the EV is excellent or the 1.6-petrol should be avoided. A little bit of both...
Georgia moves house in the Hyundai Kona, but is it as practical as it seems?
Georgia takes you through the...uninspiring...interior of our Hyundai Kona.
Georgia dissects the name Kona, as well as a few other model name mishaps...
The Kona isn't fast, but it does sound a bit furious...
Georgia gets to grips with the Hyundai Kona and it's...unique...engine/gearbox configuration.

Ask Honest John

Value my car