A fraudulent insurance claim has been made against me - how do I proceed?

A car was travelling towards me, the driver kept looking up and down into his lap and his vehicle wasn't travelling in a straight line. I took evasive action and moved slightly left as it was clear we’d otherwise have a direct impact. As we passed, our driver side mirrors took the impact. The driver demanded money for the damage to his mirror, but mine was also damaged so we met stalemate. I stated that we should call the police and he stated that later in the day I should expect an insurance claim. I visited the local police station with my statement and an electronic record was logged. My insurance company emailed me saying that the other driver blamed me for the accident and claimed for personal injury. I had reported this to them earlier that morning, sending a four page statement. The claims handler advised that this was considered a 50/50 incident in the absence of CCTV, witnesses or dashcam evidence. I received a renewal quote noted a massive insurance hike. In the claims section, it was stated that I was at fault. I contacted my insurer and was advised that they had presented an offer to the third party. They stated that the other driver had presented a medical report from a GP, and that in doing so, they could not defend this in a court of law, and had no other option. I contacted the Insurance Cheat Line. They noted my evidence and I was advised that this would be forwarded to the Insurance Fraud Bureau. Given that my proposed new insurance company required details of the claim, I contacted my previous insurer and established that they’d paid out to date, £4085 in respect of the claim. I contacted the Insurance Cheat Line with this new detail and they abruptly refused to add to the file any new information. Given that the mirrors took the impact, it is highly unlikely that the other driver was injured, especially given that speed was not a factor. My previous insurer immediately referred me to the Insurance Ombudsman and would not enter into any dialogue with me. This was because the original claims handler should have referred me to the Specialist Claims Handler when I had contacted them originally. They admit this was not the procedure followed. I'd like to know, given that I had requested police assistance and the driver had driven off after my suggestion, presented a comprehensive statement to the insurer and police station, how within six working hours he could claim personal injury and this evidence is accepted beyond my own. Furthermore, options for recourse against the driver of the other car.

Asked on 27 April 2017 by starfish27

Answered by Tim Kelly
When you see insurers complaining about fraudulent whiplash claims increasing premiums in the media, this is the reason why. It is complete apathy and laziness by your own insurer to actually handle the claim correctly. They are possibly complicit in the fraud being made against you, as they aided and assisted in a fraudulent act being made against you. The statement of, "we have been presented with a medical report so we cannot defend it" is complete rubbish. I'd like to see what injuries he had because whiplash would have been impossible and, if the incident was 50/50, then he should have only been entitled to 50 per cent of his cost. Contact www.actionfraud.police.uk/fraud-az-insurance-fraud and also contact Insurance Fraud Enforcement Department: www.cityoflondon.police.uk/advice-and-support/frau...x In terms of how he managed to do what he did so quickly, he went straight to a solicitor that uses the Ministry of Justice Portal to log, then then communicate directly with the insurer to minimise cost and going to court. They then accept what they are told as being factual. A doctor was recently struck off, and told to pay back all the compensation paid out to fraudulent claimants that he had "assessed" as having an injury, when they did not. You/the insurer still have the possibility of claiming everything back, as it is a vexatious claim.
Similar questions
A friend of mine had a minor collision recently. It happened in near stationery traffic and he went into the back of a taxi. His car only had a scratch but the taxi received a dent. The driver and passenger...
Two years ago, another vehicle reversed into mine. I was parked but in the vehicle. Minor damage to both vehicles, no personal injury. My vehicle was repaired by the main dealer, with no cost to me, claiming...
Both doors were replaced on our 2013 Ford C Max and now the alarm keeps going off at night. We get error messages for child lock malfunction, service required, drivers back door open (then the door jams...

Ask Honest John

Value my car