What's the spiritual successor to the classic 911?

About 18 years ago I bought an early Porsche 911 as a fun daily driver - now it feels too valuable for that role. What is today's equivalent?

I want a car that's characterful and nimble, but good for daily use and has potential to appreciate in value. Options that come to mind are the Mk1 Mazda MX5, Peugeot 205, early Porsche Boxster S, 924S or perhaps 911SC or Volkswagen Golf. I have a budget of £2000-£4000 but could be stretched for the right car.

Asked on 5 June 2014 by Mark H

Answered by Honest John
Early MX5s are either rusted or over-priced (or both). 205GTIs have already taken off big time. 986 Boxster Ss are asking for very expensive trouble (the 190PS 2.5 is safer). Hard to find a decent 924 or 944 and a 968 is already classic. Golf Mk I GTIs have already taken off and Mk II GTI 16vs can need a lot of work (been there). Maybe a Toyota Celica GT 190. Maybe a Z3 2.8 if you can live with the steering.
Similar questions
I want to buy a second hand roadster and have narrowed down my choice to the following two cars: 1) 2002 Porsche Boxster S 2) 2003 BMW Z4 What’s your opinion on these cars?
Growing up in the 1970s and 1980s I always hankered after a Porsche 911. Now approaching retirement that desire has returned with a mid-80s 3.0 SC being my favourite shape. Am I better off buying one...
I am thinking of buying a 2010 Mercedes-Benz SLK. I am finding a number diesel cars for sale. Do you think a diesel SLK would be a good choice over petrol? If not, which petrol engine would you recommend?
 

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer