Offered a goodwill discount on rust repair on my Audi A4 - is the quote loaded?

I have been offered a 70 per cent goodwill payment from Audi towards the repair/respray of some minor rust in the roof strips of my 2003 Audi A4 saloon. This is a very good offer for a 10-year-old car. The only problem is that they appear to have loaded the estimate for repair work so, in effect, I'm paying the full price based on other estimates from franchised body shops, including BMW and Volkswagen. My contribution would amount to £360. I welcome your advice.

Asked on 28 December 2013 by DG, Sheffield,

Answered by Honest John
Why does that not surprise me? But in the circumstances you might as well go for the Audi approved repair. The fact that your are paying towards it constitutes a contract and you then have comeback against the dealer for any subsequent problems. Had it been 100 per cent paid for out of goodwill, you would not have had any comeback in the future.
Similar questions
I have a 52 Mercedes C180 Kompressor, bought second hand, privately in May 2009. Six months later I was told (by Motoraid) all four wheel arches were rusted - the upshot of which was two new back arch...
In January 2015 I purchased a used 2013 Volkswagen Caddy van (15,000 miles) from a Volkswagen branch. So far I've needed a new rear axle replaced under warranty after it was found to be bent (Feb 2016)...
I purchased a nearly-new 2012 Ford Mondeo 1.6 Ecoboost in June 2012 with 3500miles on the clock. The car is parked on my driveway at all times when not in use. Today’s mileage is 10,000. I recently noticed...
Related models
Stylish looker with strong engines, mostly good build quality and tidy handling.

Ask Honest John

Value my car