Ask a Question

Which convertible to replace my Mercedes-Benz CLK?

My much-loved 2000 Mercedes-Benz CLK 230K cabriolet is now up to 103,000 miles, and is starting to cost serious money so I fear it has to go. I would hope to keep its replacement for at least five years and expect to do about 7000 miles a year. I fancy another drop-top but don't like later CLKs. Convertible Beetles seem a bit twee for a 66-year-old builder, and, although I like the looks of the EOS, I gather they're prone to leaks. I'm prepared to put in £10,000, plus what I can get for the Merc, and would go an extra £2000 if I found something that really lit my fire.

I haven't seen any decent Golf VI cabrios at that price so, at the moment, it looks like an A3 cabrio is about my only choice. However, there is a Mazda dealership within 400 metres of my door and they have an excellent reputation for looking after their customers, so I’m thinking about an MX-5. Is there something else I ought to consider?

Asked on by

MX-5s are excellent sports cars, but a tight squeeze inside. Might be better to look at a BMW Z4. This is less of a sportscar than a Mazda MX-5, is roomier inside, and, to my mind, would suit a builder used to a CLK far better than an MX-5. Wide engine choice.
Similar questions
We want to buy a used 2-seater convertible for under £4000 for three/four long trips every year, so we need some luggage space, comfort for distances, low wind noise with top up for motorways, reasonable...
I have a lovely 2010 BMW 318i SE Touring which is perfect. However, I am 63 yrs old and feeling the need for some serious performance with comfort. I am looking at all of these: Porsche Boxster, BMW Z4,...
When I eventually change my BMW Z4 35is, I think that the natural choice would be a Boxster S. However, I have no need for a practical car at all and wonder if a Morgan (perhaps a 2-litre 4-seater) would...
Related models
Stylish and refined roadster coupe with folding hard top. Strong performance from six-cylinder engines. Much improved steering feel came as part of 2013 revamp.
A great sports car. Incredibly nimble. Responsive steering. Easy to live with day to day. Comparatively inexpensive to run. Roof is easy to fold down.

Ask Honest John

Value my car