Do you want the Road Tax system to change? Do you have thoughts on the potential changes to the Road Tax system? | No thanks

Is it worth upgrading my 1999 BMW 528i?

In February 2000 I bought a 1999T BMW 528i Auto with 29,000 miles for £25,000. It has now done 141,000 miles and is still a pleasure to drive. The only obvious problem is the LED matrix on the dashboard is failing, but I can live with that unless it becomes an MoT issue. I have had it serviced regularly at a BMW dealership and it hasn't cost a huge amount in non-routine maintenance. Having read your comments a few times that cars are built to last around seven years I wonder whether I am on borrowed time? What can I expect to go wrong?

I currently drive about 8000 miles a year divided equally between short local trips and fortnightly motorway drives of about 260 miles. My wife and I are in our early seventies and who knows how long we will be fit to drive? I don't want to lay out a large amount of cash on a new car if I only get a couple of years out of it. On the other hand I enjoy driving so would not want to downsize on comfort and power unless my current car has serious problems.

Asked on 23 November 2013 by DP, Llandudno

Answered by Honest John
Current cars are riddled with components of relatively short design life that effectively gives them an economic life of around seven years. Your car was built before that, so it has less electronics to go wrong. The car is not worth selling. A similar 1999T BMW 523i SE auto, with 172,000 miles sold at auction for just £200 on 9 October. Best to carry on, but with the thought in the back of your mind that you will almost inevitably suffer a breakdown at some time. It's whether the potential cost and inconvenience of that breakdown is less important to you than the huge cost of shelling out on a newer car. might be able to fix that display.
Similar questions
I wonder about the way in which motoring correspondents talk about the reliability of one make of car or another. I imagine there are statistics with a certain degree of reliability, but it does seem to...
I purchased a Renault Grand Scenic four years ago when it was nearly new. I did lots of research, noted your comments, and still have the copy of your test report. We have enjoyed plenty of both UK and...
I own a BMW 528i first registered in January 2000. It has done nearly 230,000 miles and has never let me down. For the past two or three years I have been considering buying a younger model (in fact possibly...
Related models
Some great engines. Good ride and handling. Classy looks. Performed well in JD Power Customer Satisfaction surveys.

Ask Honest John Right column

Value my car