What do you think of the automatic gearboxes in the B-Class, A3 and Golf?

My shortlist of new cars is down to three: Mercedes-Benz B-Class, Audi A3 and Volkswagen Golf, all with automatic gearboxes. I am aware of your reviews that rate highly the latter two, but I also see a lot of reader reports about issues with their automatic gearboxes that I understand are identical. I like the Mercedes for its higher seating and (so easier access) and because it's roomier, but do the same issues afflict the Mercedes 7-speed gearbox?

Asked on 11 May 2013 by DW, Knutsford

Answered by Honest John
They all have 7-speed dual clutch transmissions and are comparatively fuel efficient, but there is an important difference between VAG’s DSG/S-tronic and the Mercedes-Benz system. VAG insists on an interlock forcing you to press the brake pedal before you can move the lever from N to D and this is not only irritating, it causes another problem. The brake light switch sends a signal to the ECU that the brakes are applied and as a result the ECU cuts power. The problem is that this signal can be delayed, so you can emerge from a side road on the fuel in the combustion chamber, then, halfway across the road, power is cut and you can be stranded for a second or two before the system self corrects. With the Mercedes system the lever can be moved from N to D without pressing the brake pedal. Ford and Volvo fit Getrag Powershift Dual Clutch transmissions and, again these have no interlock between N and D.
Similar questions
I am thinking of buying either a Ford Mondeo or a Volkswagen Passat, preferably an automatic. Am I right in thinking that they both use a double clutch arrangement which is essentially electronically controlled?...
I’m looking at buying a secondhand BMW 335i. I had one of the first in 2006 and always regretted selling it. I can’t drive a manual due to a disability. Looking at the BMW website, there appear to be some...
I wonder if you have had any comments about the double clutch automatic gearbox that Ford is fitting in place of the conventional epicyclic gearbox with torque converter. I recently bought a Ford Mondeo...
Related models
Loads of cabin space front and rear. Lots of safety kit. Engines are all frugal and even the most powerful deliver low CO2 emissions. All electric B Class from Spring 2015.
Comfortable and high quality premium hatchback. Low emissions diesel engines including economical 1.6 TDI. Very refined at speed yet handles well in corners.
Seventh generation Golf sets perceived quality benchmark for class. More spacious than before. Better to drive. Refined and comfortable. Multiple award winner.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car