Who’s fuelling who?

I always find V-Power fuel to be really good on engine of all the fuels that I have used over the years. Does this mean using supermarket fuels result in less mpg due to higher RPM, more carbon deposits, probably increased wear and tear on the engine?

I cannot trace any confirmed study on this issue. I have always questioned the wisdom of buying a TESCO TV as against a Sony, Panasonic, Samsung where we can see the difference. Not many would even look at the Tesco brand TV. Is there any such thing between Tesco Fuel (to include Morrisons, Asda, Sainsbury) and real oil companies such as Shell, BP, Texaco?

Asked on 29 December 2012 by RB, via email

Answered by Honest John
There have been some 'tests' that have only scratched the surface and not been conclusive. To gain an mpg benefit from using V-Power you have to drive the car differently, using lower revs in the gears to enjoy the benefit of better burn at low engine speeds. And, as you write, the real bonus is long-term due to the lack of hydrocarbon deposits in the fuel system.

I don't know anyone who has tested engines over 10,000 miles to compare V-Power with cheaper fuels. A proper test would have to be the type DEKRA use to test tyres, covering a huge mileage in 6 different cars using the two different fuels, continually swapping drivers to get consistent, honest results. As far as I know, Michelin has paid for that but Shell hasn't.
Similar questions
You mention that supermarket petrol can clog up engines and reduce MPG from the deposits in their additives. I understand that it's best to use branded super unleaded. Is it the case that branded normal...
Our 2002 Renault Scenic 1.6 automatic has clocked exactly 45,000 miles. On a recent motorway journey of 150 miles I decided to check the economy and was horrified to find it was only 26mpg. We only use...
I have an Hyundai Ioniq, which I've run exclusively on Shell fuels for the 5000 miles that I've had it. I was getting 60-62 mpg on the regular stuff, then put a tank of the V-Power in and got 64 mpg. I...

Value my car