BMW 320D Touring or A4 2.0 TDi Avant

I have been running a Passat 2.0 Tdi SE for 5 years, trouble free and doing 25k miles per year. I am now looking to replace it and am considering either a 12/18 month old 320D Touring or (from DriveTheDeal) an new A4 Avant 2.0 TDi (143).

Both are around £22 to £23k. Reliability is important, though neither manufacturer does brilliantly in recent surveys, and my mileage will be dropping to 12k per year (A roads & motorways). I plan to keep the car for about 5 years. Which would you advise? Alternatively would a petrol version be better?

Asked on 4 August 2012 by Giles

Answered by Honest John
You've been lucky with that Passat. The new Audi will keep you warranted for longer than the BMW, but the BMW will probably be easier on diesel and won't need a timing belt change after 4 years.
Similar questions
I'm going to be driving 25,000 - 30,000 miles per year (mostly motortway), and will be looking to buy a reliable and economical medium family car. I currently drive an 04 plate Golf TDi with 78,000 on...
Having been a 'petrolhead' for many years, owning a string of high performance saloons, I am afraid the time has come to change habits. With ever increasing fuel costs, car tax, insurance, poor road repairs...
I drive a 2004 530DSE which is high spec and has done 120k. I am soon to retire and will no longer need to cover the distance I previously travelled. I will still undertake journeys of 300 miles each...
Related models
High quality interior with plenty of space. Excellent steering and handling. Available with quattro four-wheel drive. Frugal 2.0 TDI. Improved for 2012 with more efficient engines.
Superb to drive. Great handling and steering. Upmarket image. Economical diesel engines culminating in amazingly efficient 320d Efficient Dynamics at 109g/km of CO2.

Value my car