Does it matter if one of my tyres has a different load rating?

Due to having had a puncture we now have a 95V rating tyre whereas all the remaining three original tyres are 91V. Is this illegal or dangerous? The supplying dealer says this is causing tyre pressure monitoring faults, the tyre dealer says it isn't a problem.

Asked on 27 March 2024 by Dr R T Rowles

Answered by David Ross
It is not illegal to use tyres of different load ratings on the same vehicle as long as they are within the minimum threshold specified by the vehicle manufacturer. In terms of safety, it is more important that the tyres on the same axle have the same or similar tread patterns and are of a similar specification - for example, if you have three economy-biased tyres you should ensure that the fourth tyre is similar.

The difference in load rating between a 91 and a 95-rated tyre is 75kg, so unless you are loading your vehicle to its maximum capacity we would not expect this to make a difference. In addition, it is unlikely that the difference in tyre specification is causing issues with the tyre pressure monitor, unless of course it is this particular tyre that is consistently producing warnings.
Similar questions
At a recent annual service for my 2017 Peugeot 3008, I requested that the front and rear wheels be swapped round so that tread wear was evened out. However, I was informed that although this was possible,...
My handbook says my tyre's load rating should be 96 but I want to fit 4 season tyres and I cannot find a supplier who has anything above 94. Would it affect my insurance if I fitted 94?
The tyre on my BMW needs changing. I contacted a BMW dealer regarding my tyre change, I was told that I will have to put the same brand of tyres on my BMW. The tyre on my BMW is a Bridgestone 225/50R18W99. Can...

Value my car

Save £75 on Warranty using code HJ75

with MotorEasy

Get a warranty quote

Save 12% on GAP Insurance

Use HJ21 to save on an ALA policy

See offer