Tyre fitter scuffed my car's alloys - do I have a legal right for them to pay for replacements?

I have just had two new tyres fitted by my local tyre fitters. During the fitting of the new tyres to the wheels, they scored each of the spokes on both alloys in a constant radius. They apologised and said that they'll get them repaired. The car is not yet three years old yet, still under warranty and only done 32,000 miles. I have had it from new. The Alloys were in perfect condition so I am very unhappy about having a repair as I have no idea if the repair will stand the test of time. Am I in my rights to demand that they pay for a new replacement pair of alloys from SEAT?

Asked on 16 March 2020 by Brian Thomas

Answered by Dan Powell
You cannot demand a new set of wheels from SEAT, but you should expect the wheels to be repaired to their previous perfect condition. If the tyre fitter is unable to do this (or if the repair is unsatisfactory) I would demand payment for a replacement set of wheels.
Similar questions
I have just purchased a new Skoda Karoq Scout with 19-inch wheels as standard. In the past three days I have managed heartbreakingly to kerb two of the wheels. In all my years of driving I cannot remember...
I damaged two of my 2015 Fiat 500 alloy wheels on a kerb and each has a small chip on the rim. Refurbishing two wheels costs £160 - £220 and I will not be sure that they are safe. Fiat wheels are £700...
I have a Mercedes-Benz E-Class which is three years old this June. Between my wife and, we have managed to scuff all the alloys a bit. Before I consider trading in, would it be better for me to have the...

Ask Honest John

Value my car