Double jeopardy

In January last year, I was stationary in my wife's car (which is fully comprehensively insured and on which I am a named driver) when someone drove into the back of me. We exchanged insurance details but subsequently the driver was found to be uninsured. Subsequently neither the insurance company nor the police have been able to trace him. My wife's car was repaired under her insurance policy. Now I am coming to reinsure both our cars I have a dilemma. I have to write on the forms that I was in an accident (non-fault but resulted in a payout) and she has to say she has made a claim. It seems like we are both being punished for one claim and as such seems unfair. Is this right? Do we just have to mention the accident/claim on one of our records?

Asked on 5 June 2010 by DK, via email

Answered by Honest John
You do have to disclose the claim when renewing both policies. It is unfair, but underwriting stats show that anyone involved in any
claim is more likely to be involved in subsequent claims than someone who isn't.
Similar questions
In February my daughter borrowed the family Fiesta as her University placements would have been impossible to get to by public transport. The car is insured in my wife's name, and she is a named driver....
I would be very grateful for your advice with what I regard as an injustice with regard to the insurer’s manner of dealing with my daughter-in-law's car insurance. 8 weeks ago, her car was stolen from...
My wife has been involved in an accident and her insurance company made an offer to settle as her car is uneconomical to repair. She has bought a new car even though she hasn't received the settlement...

Value my car