Turning Right At Traffic Lights - smilleynially
I know the answer to this question is probably in the Highway Code but I wanted to get the Back Roomer's views on it.

When you're turning right at a set of lights on a single carriage road, logic to me says that as I'm waiting, my car should be in front of the of the car wanting to do the same in the opposite direction. My car turned slightly right and the other car in front of me doing the same.

So why is it so many people will go past you and wait to turn right behind you, leaving the other cars wanting to do the same, behind that car blocking your way to turn right.

I hope you follow my point as it would be easier to get across with a diagram :-)

Would like to know which is the 'right' way..

Cheers,

Nial


Turning Right At Traffic Lights - BobbyG
Nial, know exactly what you mean and am in total agreement with you.
If cars pass each other first (which I am sure we were told to do when learning to drive) then you just end up being stuck behind the next car that is wanting to perform the same turn!
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - smilleynially
Phew! Good to know someone else thinks the same way! :-)
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Old Navy
It may depend on local custom and junction layout, at a junction near me everyone passes in front of the oncoming right turning traffic.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - smilleynially
I know at some junctions it's marked out what to do.

I should add that I live and do most of my driving in and around Central London. Just so you know the overall level of driving standards. ;-)
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - pda
Hmmm yes, something along the lines of Turkey, where he who toots the horn first has the right of way:)

I do agree though it makes sense!

Pat

Edited by pda on 23/08/2009 at 18:08

Turning Right At Traffic Lights - gordonbennet
I think most of us here learned to pass the vehicle right side to right side and turn after passing to enable a clear view of the road ahead.

A method i'm still more comfortable with, but increasingly drivers insist on passing in front of each other, and with the huge volume's turning at some junctions it can make sense.

As said some junctions are designed to make the preferred method obvious, and are indeed marked out sometimes.

I believe the old way to be much safer, i know when some folks insist on passing in front when i'm in a truck then they are completely blind to whats coming from behind me.

Amazingly in this and many other scenarios, the drivers involved get themselves into a quite obvious blind situation but seemed to have no idea before their arrival at that point that it would happen.

Edit...Hi Pat, keep the shiny side up..;)

Edited by gordonbennet on 23/08/2009 at 18:14

Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Cliff Pope
I think it depends on the particular junction. If the two side roads are very narrow it is ridiculous trying to pass behind the other car in order to do a near-impossible turn.
On the other a very wide junction may well have two or more spaces marked out for right-turning cars to queue without impeding each other.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - JH
As I recall, the highway code says go past each other and turn around the rear of the oncoming car. I don't think I've ever seen this done! Passing in front seems more logical though the view forward is not as good. You just have to be careful and observant.

May I complicate the question? What if there is a "filter right" light? My feeling is that if there is nothing coming, go, don't wait for it. After all if it weren't there you'd go. I see it as an aid at busy junctions not "thou shalt not go until it turns green".

JH
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Old Navy
We have a filter right which is a standard traffic light, so you can only move on green, (on a different junction to the one I was referring to earlier). And also ones with a stand alone green arrow, go if on or road clear and main light green.

Edited by Old Navy on 23/08/2009 at 18:37

Turning Right At Traffic Lights - enfield freddy
never realy thought about this? , just do what looks natural,

however , if a Large HGV , was turning right , and you drove down the lengh of it , and were stopped turning right by another car , if the wagon set off , it would crush you?

horrible thought , but I have seen cars crushed at junctions by HGVs

a few weeks ago , a HGV turning right on to a side road was in a two lane que , near some traffic lights , as he turned right , a large fork truck fastened to the back of it , lifted a single decker bus up onto 2 wheels , as it hit it.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Old Navy
as he turned right a large fork
truck fastened to the back of it lifted a single decker bus up onto 2
wheels as it hit it.

>>
Bus driver put himself in a dangerous position, he should have been aware of tail swing. If it was an artic that was "bent" the driver may not have been able to see the bus.

Edited by Old Navy on 23/08/2009 at 18:41

Turning Right At Traffic Lights - gordonbennet
Bus driver put himself in a dangerous position he should have been aware of tail
swing.


Difficult one Navy, all cases are different, who put themselves in the line of fire, the bus or the truck driver.
Regardless a good driver should be aware of whats happening at his rear end!? especially if the vehicle has especially long rear overhang as in this case.

In situations like this where a dangerous situation could develop i tend to straddle both lanes to stop anyone getting themselves trapped....i don't do it unless needed mind, and it is my responsibility to check before actually turning IMO.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Old Navy
Fair comment GB, I was taught to "take as much room as you need".
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - enfield freddy
yes you are correct I was/am a witness to this , as I was working close by.

at the time in Preston lancs , there was a "bus war" going on between stagecoarch and the local bus company (guess who won?)

anyway there were a large amount of "hopper" type buses running around passing each other at bus stops. those were driven by reletivly newly test passed people.

google "preston bus wars" , and see the tactics,


note now this is over , all the new buses have disapered , and we now have a fleet of old buses (local) repainted , with a rize in fares.

Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Berisford
at the time in Preston lancs there was a "bus war" going on between stagecoarch
and the local bus company (guess who won?)


Would it have been the cowboys on the stagecoach's?
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Harleyman
a few weeks ago a HGV turning right on to a side road was in
a two lane que near some traffic lights as he turned right a large fork
truck fastened to the back of it lifted a single decker bus up onto 2
wheels as it hit it.


I carry one of those things occasionally and one big problem is (assuming it's a curtain-side body) that you can't see it. It follows therefore that it is very easy to forget it's on the back and your rear overhang is a good four feet more than usual. In fact, the only time you can never forget it's on the back is when the truck is empty, it's like driving a see-saw!
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - bathtub tom
It depends on what the other, main, lights show.

If the green is a general green, then it's OK to turn right if the way is clear.

If the main light shows a green as an up arrow, then only traffic going straight ahead may proceed if the way is clear.

Green does NOT mean go!
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - pda
>>>>>Edit...Hi Pat, keep the shiny side up..;) <<<<<<

Sad day today GB, I have just hung up my keys for the last time after 29 years of lorry driving. I desperately wanted to reach 30 yrs but Arthritis and the winter coming, proved just a bit more of a challenge that I was looking for.
Instead I do a 'Train a Trainer Course at the end of September to become a Drivers CPC Trainer so I shall still be in the industry.

Sorry for going off topic Mods:)

Pat
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - smilleynially
Thanks for all the replies. I'm a rare poster on here but a frequent reader and always interested by everyone's views/posts.

I guess there is no 'right' way and common sense must prevail! :-)


Turning Right At Traffic Lights - JH
bt, yes, good point, I'd agree with that.
JH
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Old Navy
All the best Pat, at least we now have a quality car driver on the road!
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - pda
Thanks Old Navy but I have to admit.........I'm carp in a car :)

Pat
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Old Navy
Bet you can reverse!
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - gordonbennet
Thanks Old Navy but I have to admit.........I'm carp in a car :)


No you're not, you're old school and nothing on this earth would make you blow your own trumpet, apart from that if you claim to be any good then they expect perfection..;)

Sorry to hear you've hung the keys up Pat, came close to your your yard on Friday (KL to St Ives rd) and i always keep an eye out for a fair maiden at the wheel of the blue motors but never knowingly spotted you, you'd know me, look for grey haired old fool with ruddy appearance...bit like a negative.

Glad you've found a niche though and the very best of luck for the future...trust you'll keep an eye on us here and put your tuppence in often.

I've given meself 2 more years on the cars, then all being well the gaff is paid up and they (the new experts that run most car firm these days) can carry their own blasted cars.
I may well continue on the road, but i'll hopefully get something easier.

Sorry about the topic drift Mods, but the road is worse for old school proper truck drivers like Pat getting out.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Stuartli
>>Passing in front seems more logical though the view forward is not as good.>>

It is not more logical than passing each other driver's side to driver's side, which then gives both of you maximum vision of oncoming traffic.

If the oncoming traffic is held up by the car the your right waiting to turn behind you, then the first oncoming driver should leave a space for you to turn safely.

Turning right in front of an oncoming vehicle whose driver is also intending to turn right is dangerous as your view of other vehicles coming towards you, usually at speed, is considerably restricted.

Better to wait a bit longer and be sure than just another accident statistic; turning right accidents are very prevalent, many of them due to failing to ensure maximum visibility of oncoming traffic.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Natty Bumppo
I was taught to turn right by passing offside to offside, ie behind the oncoming vehicle. I believe it was referred to as a 'Manchester turn' and was supposed to give improved visibility of other traffic approaching. However nearside to nearside is the current popular method.
Both have advantages and disadvantages.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - grumpyscot
I find that in lots of places, esp major roads, there are separate right hand turn lanes. So e.g. heading west, lane going north directly faces lane ehading east but turning south. To pass offside to offside would actually mean both cars entering the "straight ahead" lanes.

We seem to have adopted the US style of passing nearside to nearside and I've found that by being observant, it's erally not a problem.

The problem arises when you (a nearside/nearside driver) wants to pass an offisde/offside driver. So I go with the nearside/nearside flow - more common and arguable more acceptable.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Sofa Spud
The advice is clear that normally you are supposed to pass each other and turn behind and that's what I normally do, even if it annoys other drivers.

Turning front-to-front is potentially more dangerous because the turning cars hide what might be following them, e.g. a motorcyclist who is going straight ahead. So, imagine, you turn across in front of a Ford Transit van who's turning across in front of you, then WHAM - motorcycle behind the van slams into you, and you end up in court charged with careless or dangerous driving.

Having said that, some junctions are laid out such that it's only practical to turn fron-to-front. Also if one or both of the turning vehicles is a large one, front-to-front is the only possible way.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - tombo
I agree with Sofa Spud. And not only is front-to-front much more dangerous unless the road is specifically laid out that way, but on a practical basis what happens is that fewer cars get through at every change of the lights. Where two or three could get forward waiting to turn if they went 'drivers' side' , if cars go front to front, then when the oncoming traffic stops only one tends to get through frustrating all those behind. As a London driver I see this added congestion every day. It might seem more logical to go front to front but in fact it's a case of short term gain for the driver at the front rather than logic.
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Alby Back
I would like to see as many traffic light controlled junctions as possible substituted with mini-roundabouts where practical. The roundabouts enforce the o/side to o/side turn and in my opinion ease and speed traffic flow. Traffic lights cause a lot of congestion in my opinion. But what do I know, I'm not on any commitees, I'm just a driver.....

;-)

Edited by Humph Backbridge on 30/08/2009 at 16:30

Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Bilboman
I think another option at *some* junctions is the "4 way stop". Perhaps it's already too late to think about introducing it here, but it's common in South Africa and the USA, where roundabouts are far less common.
All drivers stop dead on the stop line and then move off in the order of arrival. This way everyone has to wait their turn and there is never a continuous line of traffic from one "priority"road. Since there is no continuous stream of oncoming traffic, cars pass in front of opposing traffic, i.e. without passing the oncoming car first.
Surprisingly it works very well, everyone seems to remember the order almost magically and there is never an argument over who goes next.
I drove around San Francisco this month and even with all the 1 in 3 hills the 4 way stop worked perfectly. (An automatic gearbox helps enormously in San Francisco!) As I said, it is not suitable for all junctions and would require a change of mindset for most British drivers, but - why not?
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Hamsafar
HWC says turn offside to offside unless road markings say otherwise. Unless it's changed in the last few years.

Edited by Hamsafar on 30/08/2009 at 22:07

Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Berisford
Unless it's changed in the last few years.



For at least 25 years it's been;

181
When turning right at crossroads where an oncoming vehicle is also turning right, there is a choice of two methods

turn right side to right side; keep the other vehicle on your right and turn behind it. This is generally the safer method as you have a clear view of any approaching traffic when completing your turn
left side to left side, turning in front of each other. This can block your view of oncoming vehicles, so take extra care. Cyclists and motorcyclists in particular may be hidden from your view. Road layout, markings or how the other vehicle is positioned can determine which course should be taken
Turning Right At Traffic Lights - Berisford
Don't know about these days but long ago when I was an instructor learners got a little booklet with their provisional featuring 'Guidence' and 'Advice' on how to pass your test.

In that it explained about passing around the back of oncoming traffic but it also noted that at some junctions you may require 'local knowledge' and that 'your instructor' would advise if passing in front was needed.

Nice little get out for the DTp I always thought. One of the grey area's in driving tests of the time!

In places where this problem could arise* I always taught learners to 'advance slowly' and let the oncoming vehicle choose a position.

*There were only 2 places in our entire test area where this situation could ever develop so it wasn't a great problem and both those have now been sorted so...............