What is life like with your car? Let us know and win £500 in John Lewis vouchers | No thanks
automatic vs manual - Nicole17
hi,

Which is better automatic transmission or manual transmission?
automatic vs manual - Robin Reliant
You've nudged a hornet's nest asking that one. Stand by for some passionate pro and anti auto replies, depending on the posters favourite.

Seriously, if "17" denotes your age and you have not been driving very long I would go for the manual. Should you choose an auto too soon after passing your test you will lose the finer points of clutch control and gear selection before they have a chance to become a natural skill. Going back to a manual then will be pretty much like starting all over again, with stalls, kangeroo starts and nightmares when you have to move off up hill.

Autos are best left for a year or two.
automatic vs manual - Dynamic Dave
Nicole17,

Here's a couple of threads that *may* help.

www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?t=21876
www.honestjohn.co.uk/forum/post/index.htm?t=25587

Also when I ran a previous poll asking "What type of gearbox do you prefer?" the results were:-
Automatic = 42
Manual = 46





automatic vs manual - Cardew(USA)
Modern automatics enable you to do everything a manual gearbox can do - except stall!

The problem is that they carry a penalty in purchase price, economy and performance.

automatic vs manual - Happy Blue!
Learn to drive on a manual, get a couple of years experience on one and then, if you can afford it and you do mainly urban driving, get an auto.

I will only have autos, but then I do 95% urban driving and I can afford the extra costs.

Do you see pilots changing gear in a Cessna?
--
Espada III - well if you have a family and need a Lamborghini, what else do you drive?
automatic vs manual - patently
Do you see pilots changing gear in a Cessna?
--


Well, not in the classic Cessna 152 in which I learnt to fly, but many other prop aircraft have a form of gearing - known as the constant speed propellor since it allows you to choose a specific rpm for the prop.

You have a lever to move the prop angle from fine to coarse - some can be left at any point in between. The purpose is to achieve the same effect as a gearshift, in many ways.
automatic vs manual - Happy Blue!
Yes Patently, but do you press a clutch pedal to vary the pitch of the propellor?
--
Espada III - well if you have a family and need a Lamborghini, what else do you drive?
automatic vs manual - patently
Yes Patently, but do you press a clutch pedal to vary
the pitch of the propellor?


There are plenty of other things to keep you busy! And you asked if pilots changed gear - which some do....

;-)
automatic vs manual - Malcolm_L
VAG DSG autobox only has a purchase price penalty. Some DSG models are quicker than their manual equivalents.

If only it was a no cost option!
automatic vs manual - NowWheels
Does anyone know why VAG offers the multitronic in the Audi, but the DSG in similarly-powered engines in VW models? (e.g 2.0TDI is DSG in the Touran, but multitronic in the A4)