DIY Oil Analysis - RT

Has anyone used DIY oil analysis kits - eg MotorCheckUp www.thedroptest.co.uk/motorcheckup.html

Opie Oils, well regarded by most entusiasts, has started selling them.

Are there any alternatives ?

DIY Oil Analysis - Hamsafar

Looks like a load of rubbish. Oil analysis is usually done by comparing the results of mass spectrometry of a sample of the oil when new and when used - not soaking it up a peice of blotting paper and comparing the shades of brown.

Edited by Hamsafar on 06/01/2014 at 21:38

DIY Oil Analysis - Andrew-T

Might be a bit of hi-tech paper chromatography?

DIY Oil Analysis - madf

"After 15 minutes you will be able to see whether there are unusually high levels of grime, moisture or fuel in the oil, things that can indicate an underlying problem with the engine"

Grime

moisture

fuel

Sounds a limited test but Ok if those are what you need to test for,, Many tests are for metals - bearing wear. Clealry not inlcuded.

You get what you pay for. or so I hope.

DIY Oil Analysis - Gibbo_Wirral

Take a look at this picture from their site:

www.thedroptest.co.uk/images/motorcheckup-slidesho...g

Anyone who's had a diesel will tell you that the oil goes black in no time. It doesn't mean its bad.

Edited by Gibbo_Wirral on 07/01/2014 at 13:08

DIY Oil Analysis - Ordovices

This used to be a standard test in the military vehicle test kit for assessing the quality (combustion product loading in a detergent oil) of diesel engine oil, along with a viscosity comparison to a new oil sample contaminated with (5%?) diesel and clean oil, in conjunction with a "Speedy" moisture test (put some oil in a can with a pressure gauge attached, add calcium hydride, shake and pray).

It has been replaced with a more modern test kit (Kittiwake) and a programme of spectrographic oil analysis, but its roots have some validity, if I recall correctly the blackness of the spot after a period of resting (24 hrs?)was compared to a standard sample in a kind of "go/no go" test.

DIY Oil Analysis - dadbif
ISTR a chap calling himself "unthrottled" who used to post on here, detailing a prices with a piece if blotting paper that gave the same results. I cannot find it at the moment, but it ma be worth trawling the forum, it was free....
DIY Oil Analysis - galileo

in conjunction with a "Speedy" moisture test (put some oil in a can with a pressure gauge attached, add calcium hydride, shake and pray).

I think the substance would be calcium carbide, in the days when I worked in a foundry laboratory this was how we tested moisture content of moulding sand. The moisture reacts to form acetylene gas, same process for headlamps before electric ones.

DIY Oil Analysis - Andrew-T

Calcium hydride will give you hydrogen, so the overall result will be similar. Both potentially explosive ....

Carbide probably keeps better though.

Edited by Andrew-T on 07/01/2014 at 23:13