Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - dave321

I'm currently driving a Ford Focus MK3 Hatchback, and as far as hatchbacks go, it's pretty spacious in the boot and for passengers.

I am however looking for something bigger, that I can fit in a pram and some extra bits and two car seats in the backseat without it feeling cramped.

I know estates exist but I would like to avoid them (can't get the wife to agree to them!). Any other hatchback would feel like a sideways move.

It would need to be automatic. And ULEZ compliant. And be nice to drive on the occasional motorway trip.

I did have the "German luxury" itch a few days ago and started looking at 10 year old 5 Series', but they're so gosh darn long. E Classes only come in Diesel from that age if I remember correctly, which means it's not suitable for me. And I guess the upkeep costs of these 2 cars would be far too much.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - RT

How about a Skoda Superb - it has all the attributes of German quality without the badge or price.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - gordonbennet

Tourer Avensis Tourer is a more pleasing looker than the saloon version, see what the good lady thinks to one of those, petrol version best.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - catsdad

How about a Honda Civic? The model that ceased in 2017 has a much bigger boot than it appears. Also magic seats are great to free more space.

Despite being a least 8 years old, they are holding their value and you might have to up your budget or accept an older car. However avoid going as old as 2012 as cars from that year had an oil consumption issue. That’s why I traded in my manual one in 2019.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - gordonbennet

Tourer Avensis Tourer is a more pleasing looker than the saloon version, see what the good lady thinks to one of those, petrol version best.

Should have read Toyota Avensis Tourer....plot lost.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - John F

I know estates exist but I would like to avoid them (can't get the wife to agree to them!).

For at least 2 children and their gubbins an estate is almost essential! What are wife's cons which outweigh the pros? I suspect one might be the false impression of increased length with associated parking difficulty but actually most estates are much the same length as their saloon equivalent. I also vote for a Superb....or a Mondeo.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - Big John

Skoda Superb already mentioned but you might find it too long. Fab car though. Huge boot in hatch or estate versions.

Or how about a Skoda Octavia? - also has a huge boot in hatch or estate versions. When I had a young family fairly early on I acquired a Skoda Octavia which swallowed all the family gubbins and some...

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - dave321

So what I'm getting from here is stay away from E Class and 5 Series, and go with a Skoda.

Stay away from the luxury (MB and BMW) brands because they are money pits?

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - catsdad

Skoda would seem to meet your space requirements. However their automatic DSG gearboxes have earned a reputation for problems. I believe recent versions are much improved but your budget means you’d be considering an older one. If so it’s worth doing specific research on DSG issues and knowing what to look for.

I would still be looking at traditional torque converter gearboxes. If not German then Japanese.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - Engineer Andy

I'm currently driving a Ford Focus MK3 Hatchback, and as far as hatchbacks go, it's pretty spacious in the boot and for passengers.

I am however looking for something bigger, that I can fit in a pram and some extra bits and two car seats in the backseat without it feeling cramped.

I know estates exist but I would like to avoid them (can't get the wife to agree to them!). Any other hatchback would feel like a sideways move.

It would need to be automatic. And ULEZ compliant. And be nice to drive on the occasional motorway trip.

I did have the "German luxury" itch a few days ago and started looking at 10 year old 5 Series', but they're so gosh darn long. E Classes only come in Diesel from that age if I remember correctly, which means it's not suitable for me. And I guess the upkeep costs of these 2 cars would be far too much.

Well, for ULEZ compliance, and auto and only the occasional longer trip, then petrols, avoiding dual clutch (generally) and Jatco-made autos are best bet for a stress-free (i.e. reliable) ownership experience, assuming you can source a car with a proven maintenance history.

The good thing is that with petrols, any EU4 car is compliant, but for diesels, the much newer (10-15 years) EU6 compliance is needed. That makes them both more complex (can be unreliable, especially when mainly used in the urban setting) and a good deal more expensive

When you've come up with a list, make sure you check them out in person, including getting a test drive (preferably from cold across a decent range of roads/speeds) to ensure they will be comfortable and big enough for your needs.

That will necessitate bringing along all the bits you intend to pout in the boot to 'try it out', as some advertise quite large spaces but in reality they include the area under the normal boot floor in the total boot space, plus it might have an odd-shaped boot or a cross bracing on the floor which may prevent fitting certain larger items in.

You may also want to look at some MPVs and SUVs/crossovers that may suit your needs. Be prepared to accept some lower mpg cars because they use the traditional torque converter auto boxes, which are reliable but at the cost of about 10-20% mpg over manuals, CVT and DCT autos.

One left field choice might be the KIA Venga 1.6 auto or its Hyundai ix30 equivalent. Decent size boot at around 400L if I recall, just not exactly great along the country roads handling and ride quality wise.

Fine other than that, though if you can, get a post gearbox upgrade one (~2015-16) that has the more efficient 6 speed box rather than the original 4 speed one, which only does low 30s mpg. It won't set records for speed, but they are practical and seemingly quite hardy. Quite a few coming back to main dealers now as PXes and look in decent condition.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - Adampr

Skoda Rapid/Seat Toledo has a pretty much unbeatable combination of rear space, boot space and small dimensions. However, as above, the auto is a DSG which is not necessarily the most reliable.

I am a bit confused about your desire for not a hatchback, not an estate but must be able to accommodate a pram. Is your wife after an SUV?

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - Big John

I am a bit confused about your desire for not a hatchback, not an estate but must be able to accommodate a pram. Is your wife after an SUV?

and if an SUV consider that many have a smaller footprint re boot - albeit taller but overall usually smaller than a hatch. estate. Also SUVs tend to be more expensive. However one advantage can be easier access through the taller rear doors to secure children into car seats.

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - Big John

Skoda Rapid/Seat Toledo

Yup, also has a big boot. When my son bought his 2016 Octavia back in 2019 we tried a few Rapids and in comparison the interiors seemed a bit er - primitive and the Octavia was significantly more refined comparing versions fitted with the same engine (EA211.2tsi in his case). Fast forward to 2025 and that Octavia has never missed a beat but it has a manual gearbox.

Edited by Big John on 14/07/2025 at 21:17

Struggling to choose cars for under £8.5k, family - Adampr

I had a Toledo. The interior was indeed a bit...er..primitive. Brilliant for kids though as everything is made of incredibly hard plastic.