Do I have to allow a garage three attempts to resolve a fault with my new car before instituting a rejection process?

I purchased a pre-reg Mazda MX-5 2.0-litre from a dealership with 170 miles on it in the summer of 2017. The handling got progressively worse and I took it back to the dealership for investigation a few days before the six month anniversary of its purchase (its mileage was now 3300). Investigation has shown the rear differential has failed and it has been replaced under warranty. A separate issue of a rusting rear brake disk was also dealt with under warranty (both disks skimmed) and assumed to be linked to the failed differential. However the handling issues remain, albeit slightly reduced, and a comparison drive with an identical vehicle from the dealer showed that there is still something wrong with the car. The vehicle remains at the dealership for ongoing investigations. What can I do if the dealership is unable to fix the problem to my satisfaction? Do I have to allow them three attempts to resolve the problem before instituting a rejection process? My concern is that the differential failure is not the source of the handling problem but a symptom of another material fault with the car and given that it is a sports car these early significant problems give me concern.

Asked on 8 January 2018 by Matt Wilks

Answered by Honest John
The handling of this car should be precise and excellent, though, of course, it's much more powerful and therefore quicker than the 1.5-litre. Unlike the 1.5 it should have a limited slip diff. You'd better make sure the limited slip diff was not replaced with a standard diff from a 1.5. So worth checking the tyres and getting a 'four way laser alignment' of all the suspension at a branch of www.alignmycar.co.uk / They will be able to fix it, but if they can't then you can talk rejection, though you will have to pay a fair price for the 3000 miles you have driven it.
Similar questions
I bought a 2014 Audi A3 S-Line from Norwich Audi, they delivered it to me in Coventry, sight unseen and from the day I received the car it had an unusual noise coming from the engine. They directed me...
I bought a brand new car in March this year. When it rained, the water leaked into the car. I sent it to the dealer to fix it, but it's not been successful and it still lets water in. What can I do? Should...
I had a new Volkswagen Golf delivered on 11 April with 120 miles on it. Four hours later with 200 miles on it, the car went into limp mode. It was taken to a Volkswagen main dealer and I was supplied with...
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car