I bumped into a car and the driver is now inflating the claim - what do you advise?

I bumped the towbar of the car in front of me (both vehicles are Volkswagen Passat Estates). The damage to my car was a cracked number plate and a small dent in the plastic plate behind the number plate with no other damage at all. It cost me £10 for a new number plate. He is claiming that I bent his towbar and that his car is so damaged that it might be a write off. I've told my insurance company this, but am concerned that this very minor accident might cause trouble for me later with the so-called excessive damage to his car. Can you advise what I can do about this?

Asked on 1 December 2017 by Nick H

Answered by Tim Kelly
It makes no difference to you personally whether he just has a scratch to his bumper or you write his car off. The effect on your policy and premium is the same.

Leave it to your insurer, it is their responsibility to ensure any claim made against you is not vexatious. If his car has a tow bar fitted, it will need a tow-ball fitted at the least (they can fracture) and it is possible the vehicle has further damage than what may appear evident.
Similar questions
I have recently been involved in an incident where I reversed out of my relatives' driveway and was stationary on the roadside. A neighbour then reversed out of a parking bay and reversed into my door....
I was sitting in my Toyota RAV4, with a towbar fitted, at a set of traffic lights when I was rear ended. I thought there was no real damage, but when I went to fill up with petrol the next day, it was...
While sorting out insurance for my new car, I've been informed by my new insurer that there's a claim on my insurance for an incident that was reported on the 17 March 2017. There was an incident in a...
Related models
Relaxing and quiet to drive. Packed with the latest technology. Manifold in head diesel engines. Trailer assist works brilliantly. Spacious boot.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car