I need to buy a reliable estate car for 7000 miles per year - should I consider a diesel?

I need an estate car with good reliability, and I want an automatic with reasonable economy. I have about £10,000 plus my trade-in. I am thinking of a used Passat, Mazda 6 or Volvo V70 and I know from reading the motoring press that the diesel versions of these estates are significantly more economical than the petrol versions, but my mileage is only 7000 miles a year and I recall you saying that low mileage does not warrant a diesel. Why is that with diesel prices only a couple of pence more than petrol?

Asked on 18 August 2010 by Hywel

Answered by Honest John
Add a Ford Mondeo estate to your list, but forget about diesel for 7000 miles a year. The diesel particulate filter fitted to EU5 diesels won't like this sort of mileage one bit.
Similar questions
I'm looking to replace both a 54-plate 2.0-litre automatic petrol Ford Mondeo and a 2007 1.4-litre manual Fiesta with a newer Mondeo, which will cover 8000 to 10,000 miles a year. I've noticed that you...
New Golf 1.4TSI petrol or new 1.6TDI diesel? I’ve done the maths. For both cars after three years at 8000 miles per year at urban mpg (43 petrol and 62 diesel) and local fuel prices I’ve calculated petrol...
In last Saturday's paper, you advised someone who does 10,000 miles a year that 'You don't do enough miles for a diesel.' I'd appreciate your opinion as to what mileage would suggest the need for a diesel,...
Related models
Neatly styled, entry-level models a good balance of ride and handling, excellent 2.2-litre diesel engine.
Spacious and comfortable. Wide range of engines. Big, boot with lockable seatbacks. Generally better from May 2008 onwards.
Big and practical estate. Perfect for families. Good cabin quality. Plenty of safety kit as standard.
Fantastic to drive. Refined and comfortable to travel in. Massively roomy cabin and huge load capacity. Excellent value. Efficient ECOnetic models.

Ask Honest John

Value my car