Buying a new SUV - SEAT Ateca or Mazda CX-3?

I have decided to get myself a car and want to get an SUV. However, with more than 50 different models on sale, I can’t make a decision on which one to buy. I have test driven the SEAT Ateca and Mazda CX-3. The Mazda has the 2.0 petrol automatic AWD, while the SEAT uses the 2.0 diesel with the DSG gearbox. Which one would you buy?

I understand you recommend the Dacia Duster and Toyota C-HR. However, the Toyota only has four-wheel drive with a CVT transmissions and I can’t stand the high pitched whine of that every time I hit the gas pedal. The Duster is a good car, but too simple for my tastes.

Asked on 1 December 2016 by Driver

Answered by Honest John
Never ever dismiss the Dacia Duster unless status is worth paying an extra £5k - £7k for an equivalent car. Dan Powell drove the Ateca 2.0TDI. I drove the Ateca 1.0TSI. VAG has improved its diesels enormously since the NOx disaster, but if you won't be doing at least 15k miles a year, don't get a diesel. A new alternative is the Toyota C-HR hybrid that seems slow in comparison to the 1.2 petrol manual, but in reality we were pulling high speeds from it and the handling beats any other Crossover, including the Ateca: www.honestjohn.co.uk/road-tests/toyota/toyota-c-hr.../

The Ateca 2.0TDI has VAG's new seven-speed dual WET CLUTCH DSG that overcomes the problems of the old seven-speed dual dry clutch DSG and the hesitations of the old six-speed dual wet clutch DSG, so it should be okay. No problems yet reported with the EA288 diesel. No reports of AdBlue consumption, which might be as good as 5000 per 10 litre container that retails at around £16. No reason to put you off the Ateca.
Similar questions
Car manufacturers are continuing to manufacture diesel cars despite all the adverse publicity about diesel. Nearly all motoring websites continue to recommend diesel as the best buy in versions of automatic,...
I'd like to buy a diesel BMW X3 2.0 but most of my journeys are short. What would be the negative effects on the car from my driving pattern? Are there any small changes to my driving, like doing a 50-mile...
I'm looking at putting my order in for a 2017 Audi Q5, but should I go for a petrol or diesel 2.0-litre? My mileage, 8000 a year, and the current diesel backlash would suggest petrol is the right choice....
Related models
Enjoyable and good to drive. Good quality interior finish. 2.0-litre petrol is smooth and economical.
Very comfortable and refined with impressive ride quality. Lots of room for those in the back along with a large boot. Good value for money. 1.6 TDI should prove very economical. Five star Euro NCAP rating.
 

Ask Honest John

Value my car