Should I buy the Audi A3, Volkswagen Passat or Skoda Superb?

I have now decided to select one of these cars, which are all 1.6 diesel automatics: Audi A3 sedan, Volkswagen Passat or Skoda Superb. According to my opinion, Audi is the best quality among them, but it is a little bit narrow in comparison to others. In addition, it has a high middle tunnel that is the cause of difficulties for sitting in the middle. The Passat's back side is a little bit wider than the Audi and in addition, fuel consumption may be higher than the Audi. The Superb is largest compared to the others, but a little bit cheaper feeling and with higher fuel consumption. And used market value is worst. We are three persons in the family: two adults and one child. These cars are similar prices, and all have different positive and negative criteria. Reliability, usable comfort, service prices and secondhand value are important for me. But I cannot decide between them.

Asked on 16 November 2013 by ME, Turkey

Answered by Honest John
These all have identical drivetrains, the same belt cam 1.6TDI engine and the same DSG dual clutch transmission (called s-tronic in the Audi, but the same). The A3 is the classiest and most likely to retain value. But none are better built than the others because they share the same components. The Superb is now the oldest model, dating back to 2008. The Passat dates back to 2011. The A3 sedan is this year's car.
Similar questions
I was looking at a used Volkswagen Touran but test-drove one and wasn't happy with it. As we are a four-member family, we don't really need seven seats, more a good size boot for weekend trips away. I...
We are looking for a new car, preferably a forecourt model or demonstrator with less than 5000 miles on the clock so we can avoid instant depreciation. We currently drive a 2003 Clio Billabong and have...
I have been a keen follower of your column and am writing to you as I am now finally in a position to buy my first sports car, having saved up for many years. I am looking at secondhand cars and am looking...
Related models
Limousine-like amounts of rear legroom. Clever dual tailgate means it's both a hatch and a saloon. GreenLine model is very economical. A lot of car for the money.
Incredibly spacious as a saloon or estate, excellent range of engines and trim levels, comfortable and refined on the move.
Comfortable and high quality premium hatchback, low emissions diesel engines including economical 1.6 TDI, very refined at speed yet handles well in corners.
 

Value my car